management theory of complex evolutionary systems | Competivation
Connecting causal AI with complex evolutionary systems

Connecting causal AI with complex evolutionary systems

In the field of artificial intelligence (AI), a paradigm shift is currently underway from purely statistical correlations to dynamic cause-and-effect models. The theory of complex, evolutionary systems—which our expert network Competivation has been applying to real-world management problems for several years—offers a promising foundation for this causal AI. The goal is to integrate these two lines of development. Investor interest in the Heidelberg-based startup Kausable AI demonstrates just how great the potential of this paradigm shift is.

In our new blog post, I explain how the management theory of complex, evolutionary systems can help causal AI achieve a breakthrough.

 

Early-stage investment in Kausable AI

AI models trained on historical data reach their limits when something unexpected occurs. They then have to be adjusted through a time-consuming process. The Heidelberg-based company Kausable AI started with the idea that a new generation of models must learn to cope better with constant change. To this end, Kausable has received an early-stage investment of 12 million euros from venture capitalists and renowned AI researchers. The model, trained using synthetic data, is designed to understand causes and effects, derive hypotheses from them, and learn from results to master new challenges. Whether this approach will work remains to be seen, but the need is great, as tackling complex problems is becoming increasingly demanding. For example, with their project TipPFN, the founders are attempting to identify tipping points at which systems suddenly change.1

In this context, innovative AI models require a practical theoretical foundation.

 

Applying the theory of complex, evolutionary systems to real-world management problems

I recently described the development of the theory of complex evolutionary systems and its application to real-world management problems in an article.2 For this connection with an AI that understands causes and effects, certain characteristics of these systems are significant, which I would like to briefly explain. This is particularly true with regard to the complex interactions between different levels, such as geopolitics, the environment, states, regions, companies, and administrations, as well as individuals and society.

The implications for designing multilevel strategies are profound. AI support can help mitigate the shortcomings of traditional management practices.

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

A defining characteristic of complex, evolutionary systems is openness. It is therefore important to understand the influence of environmental factors at every level of the system. Currently, the interplay of various risks poses a new type of threat to the German economy.

This environment is characterized by high dynamism. Consequently, all relevant stakeholders face the challenge of developing a growth mindset. Leadership and human resources development provide important impetus for such a self-image.

Another key characteristic is interconnectedness. AI can help model the complex connectivity between levels and stakeholders. For example, problems related to the energy transition in the past have arisen from barriers between the sectors of politics, science, business, and society.

The nonlinearity of these processes is often underestimated. This refers to the realization that small events can have major effects. However, these effects are usually only recognized after tipping points have been reached.

A hallmark of many strategies is emergence. Contrary to the widespread belief that top management develops strategies, these often originate with individuals possessing exceptional foresight and spread from the outside or from the bottom up through the hierarchy.

Path dependence is also underestimated. This refers to the importance of initial conditions for subsequent processes. A typical example is strategies that are logically sound but fail due to a toxic organizational culture.

Complex, evolutionary systems are characterized by adaptivity. This adaptation to new developments amid high uncertainty has reached an extreme level due to the current geopolitical situation.

As a result, the framework conditions for self-organization are becoming increasingly important. Successful digital companies rely on the work of competent, agile teams. On the other hand, in “old-school” personnel management, agility is still a foreign concept.

Closely linked to this is the importance of learning loops. One indicator that these iterative learning processes are working is when leaders do not fall victim to a “transformation illusion” and believe that a new, stable state of equilibrium is achievable.

Understanding complex, evolutionary systems plays a key role in helping causal AI achieve a breakthrough. To this end, it is important to examine the significance of the three levels of a causality ladder for dynamic cause-and-effect models.

 

Significance of the three levels of the causality ladder

The significance of the three levels of causality developed by Turing Award winner Judea Pearl lies in overcoming the limitations of pure pattern recognition to create systems that understand cause-and-effect relationships, run through hypothetical scenarios, and act in a comprehensible manner. Pearl distinguishes between the levels of observation, action, and reflection.3

The first level of observation (association) involves capturing data and patterns. This is the foundation of classical deep learning. The problem here is that while these systems recognize correlations, they do not recognize causalities—in other words, they do not understand the “why.” When the framework conditions change (dataset shift), traditional AI models often fail.

The focus of the second level of action lies on actively intervening in a system and altering variables. At this stage, causal AI moves beyond its passive role. It can predict, to a limited extent, what might happen.

The third level of reflection (counterfactual thinking) explores alternative scenarios as part of a retrospective analysis. This stage bridges the gap to human cognition. It enables AI to truly learn from mistakes through hypothetical simulations.

For a definitive breakthrough in causal AI, progress is currently still lacking in the following four key areas:

  1. Automatic structure discovery. To identify cause and effect from observational data (causal discovery), the involvement of human experts with methodological and subject-matter expertise is required.
  2. The development of standardized software frameworks. There is a lack of both universal, easily understandable software libraries for specific applications and benchmarks for measuring the performance of causal models.
  3. A lack of real-world data regarding causality levels two and three. To simulate complex application domains, better methods for generating synthetic data are needed.
  4. The connection to deep learning. The strength of causal AI lies in logical thinking. Deep learning excels at processing unstructured data. Research institutes and tech giants are working to merge these two worlds (causal deep learning).

An AI-supported application of the theory of complex evolutionary systems in management practice focuses on these key areas.

 

Cooperation among different stakeholder groups

When combining causal AI with complex, evolutionary systems, cooperation among various stakeholder groups plays a crucial role. These groups include:

  • Management researchers and consultants who apply the theory of complex evolutionary systems, as well as
  • practitioners who have experience with the current challenges facing companies and government agencies.

These two groups provide the “human-in-the-loop” prior knowledge and should safeguard this valuable resource. In addition to this experiential level, there is the level of technology and infrastructure. Here, the following groups are active:

  • AI experts who work on the further development and commercialization of causal AI and its algorithms, as well as
  • cloud providers who enable the use of a trustworthy infrastructure and its scalability.

In the past, our network of experts has found that the connectivity among these stakeholders is a key success factor. In this respect, the topic is another building block of the fifth stage of development in connective strategic management, a concept we have coined.4

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

It is important to recognize that, even for digital giants, causal AI is something like the “Holy Grail” of the next generation of AI. Such “Next AI” relies more heavily on the Socratic method of critical, step-by-step questioning to reduce the hallucinations typical of language models.5 An interesting application of causal AI is the development of positive visions of the future through strategic foresight.

 

Development of positive visions of the future

Strategic foresight has a long history of development. Although the term “foresight” was not coined until the 1980s, key methods—such as scenario analysis—emerged as early as the 1960s, when research institutes in the U.S. shifted their focus from the military to the private sector following World War II.

The Game-Changer Radar, which we developed several years ago, aims to identify profound changes at an early stage in order to capitalize on emerging opportunities before competitors do.6 We used this method in our book on AI as a game changer, published in 2020.7

Strategic foresight should focus more on designing positive visions of the future that view the future as a space of possibilities that can be shaped.8  Causal AI can help systematically think through possible developments and interactions. Such visions of the future serve as the starting point for compelling narratives that foster a stronger emotional connection. Germany urgently needs such a narrative at this time.

 

Conclusion

  • Causal AI has the potential to prepare organizations for unexpected changes more effectively and cost-efficiently than traditional AI models
  • The application of the theory of complex, evolutionary systems in management and the characteristics of this theory provide an important foundation for causal AI
  • This theoretical base can contribute to a breakthrough in causal AI. This requires cooperation among different stakeholder groups
  • In practice, there is a great need for positive visions of the future, which we develop with the help of AI-supported strategic foresight.

 

References

[1] Bomke, L., Renowned AI Researchers Are Backing These German Founders. In: Handelsblatt, July 24, 25, and 26, 2026, p. 31

[2] Servatius, H.G., Learning to Design Solutions for Complex Management Problems. In: Competivation Blog, July 15, 2025

[3] Pearl, J., Mackenzie, D., The Book of Why – The New Science of Cause and Effect, New Edition, Basic Books 2026

[4] Servatius, H.G., Connective Strategic Management in the AI Era. In: Competivation Blog, May 22, 2026

[5] Bomke, L., Dehari, L., Fokuhl, J., Training AI with Socrates. In: Handelsblatt, August 12, 2026, pp. 26-27

[6] Servatius, H.G., Strategic Foresight with a Game-Changer Radar. In: Competivation Blog, January 27, 2021

[7] Kaufmann, T., Servatius, H.G., The Internet of Things and Artificial Intelligence as Game Changers – Paths to Management 4.0 and a Digital Architecture, SpringerVieweg 2020

[8] Schön, N., Peters, N., Europe Urgently Needs More Future Competence. In: Handelsblatt, August 5, 2026, p. 14

Learning to design solutions for complex management problems

Learning to design solutions for complex management problems

In light of major challenges such as the resilient, digital, and ecological realignment of companies, industries, and regions, the proportion of problem-oriented learning in education and training must increase. The ability to design solutions for complex management problems is crucial for success. Management theory for complex evolutionary systems provides an important foundation for this. The application of this approach, which has developed over the last few decades, has hardly been taught at business schools to date. One practical approach is the DSCMP method, which we have tested in many projects. DSCMP stands for Designing Solutions for Complex Management Problems.

 

In this new blog post, I explain the theoretical foundations of the DSCMP method and a general framework that can be adapted to specific problem situations.

 

What students and practitioners find difficult

An exam question that most students find difficult is: Using an example, explain a concept and approach for AI-based strategic realignment. It makes little difference whether the question asks for a digital or ecological realignment. However, designing solutions for complex management problems is not only difficult for students, but also for experienced practitioners in companies. Apparently, neither group is familiar with suitable theoretical foundations or a practical approach that they could apply. I would therefore like to begin by explaining the theory.

 

Management theory of complex evolutionary systems

Management theory of complex evolutionary systems has emerged from the combination of three lines of development, the application of which in management enables better strategic realignments.1 These paths, which I outline below, are:

  1. The path from ecosystems to system theories
  2. the application of evolutionary theories in economics, and
  3. a transfer of the theory of complex adaptive systems to the solution of management problems.

The term ecosystem was defined by biologist Arthur Tansley (oikos, the house, and systema, the connected) in 1935, among others. The field of cybernetics, which has been shaped by Norbert Wiener and others since the 1940s, deals with the control of systems. In 1959, Stafford Beer defined the term management cybernetics.2  Since the 1950s, a general systems theory has developed. According to this theory, open systems are in dynamic exchange with their environment. The sociological systems theory founded by Talcott Parsons regards actions as constitutive elements of social systems. In 1951, Parson developed the AGIL scheme (adaptation, goal attainment, integration and latency) for the structural and functional analysis of social systems.3 At the University of St. Gallen, Hans Ulrich has been developing the concept of system-oriented management theory since the 1960s.4 Since the 1990s, the terms economic, stakeholder, start-up, and AI ecosystems have gained importance.

Evolutionary theories (from evolvere, to develop) have a long history in various disciplines. Of particular importance for economics is the concept of spontaneous order developed in the 1960s by Friedrich August von Hayek, who later won the Nobel Prize in Economics (1974).5 This is the result of self-organizing processes that emerge over time and are based on rules that can change. An important basis for the concept of an evolutionary organizational theory of the Munich School around Werner Kirsch6 is the theory of communicative action developed by the philosopher Jürgen Habermas.7 An evolutionary process in management is characterized by a dynamic sequence of imbalances.

The interdisciplinary theory of complex adaptive systems was developed at the Santa Fe Institute in New Mexico (USA), which was co-founded in 1984 by Nobel Prize winner in physics Murray Gell-Mann (1969). Such a system absorbs information about its environment and its own interaction with this environment, recognizes patterns, and condenses them into competing models. The resulting actions feed back into these models. An important management recommendation is to create suitable conditions for more self-organized interaction between competent actors.8 Agile methods are based on this. The theory of complex responsive relationship processes emphasizes the importance of local, nonlinear interactions between actors, which give rise to patterns that are difficult to predict.9

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

The theory of complex evolutionary systems has initiated a paradigm shift in strategic management, which has been driven primarily by successful digital companies since the 1990s.10 The characteristics of this management theory, which is new to many established companies, are openness, dynamism, connectedness, non-linearity, emergence, path dependency, adaptivity, self-organization, and learning loops.

The question now is how this theoretical foundation can help teachers and learners in practice to design solutions for complex management problems.

 

Approach using the DSCMP method

The DSCMP method was developed as part of our consulting, teaching, and research activities. Consultants are usually called in when organizations are looking for support in solving complex management problems. However, consulting only leads to lasting success if managers and employees are successfully taught the relevant skills.

Designing solutions for complex management problems requires a conceptual framework that project teams can adapt to the situation at hand. The following figure shows the main phases of the iterative process used in the DSCMP method. The didactic challenge lies in teaching the ability to adapt this approach to new complex problems.

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

In the DSCMP method, the first phase involves forming interdisciplinary program and project teams that report to a management committee. The structure and composition of these teams may change as the work progresses.

In phase 2, the task is to bring together relevant information and different perspectives. The goal is to understand a complex problem and its causes and describe it as accurately as possible.

This is followed by the important step of designing creative solutions that bring everything together. Examples include the development of a hydrogen value chain and the conversion to climate-resilient cities. Communication with stakeholders from politics, science, and society is becoming increasingly important but is difficult to implement.11 Such cooperation requires dialogue-based action based on a position of strength, e.g., with the help of new methods such as connective design.

Depending on the type of problem, possible approaches can be tested in pilot solutions, prototypes, or minimum viable products.

A variety of methods have been developed for testing the „pilots.“ It is also important to identify implementation difficulties and adapt the solutions in rapid learning loops.

The implementation of a promising solution begins with planning the scaling and further financing. The Objectives and Key Results (OKR) method has proven useful for formulating goals and key results.

The final phase is then the implementation of scaling within the framework of programs and projects, a review of success, and regular reflection on interim results.

The success of such an approach depends crucially on the skills and mindset of the teams and managers involved.

 

Implications for management education

Important implications for management education can be summarized in three points:12

  1. Learning from complex current problems
  2. interdisciplinary work on these problems in projects
  3. the use of teachers with leadership experience.

The reality at most universities is far from this. However, this opens up a wide range of opportunities for innovative education providers. In our practical work, we use the DSCMP method in bachelor’s and master’s degree programs as well as directly in companies as part of customized management education. One focus of our research is on supporting problem-oriented project-based learning through artificial intelligence (AI). The benefit for all learners lies in improving their chances in a labor market that is currently undergoing dramatic change.

 

Artificial intelligence (AI) is changing the world of work

Dario Amodei, founder of the AI start-up Anthropic, predicts that AI will destroy half of all entry-level office jobs. Classic clerical work, which is characterized by repetitive, analytical, and administrative tasks, will be particularly affected. This makes it all the more important for job seekers to be able to demonstrate AI skills. Past experience with digitalization shows that jobs tend to change rather than disappear completely. It is therefore important to first learn how to use AI to perform time-consuming tasks more productively, thereby gaining more time to solve complex problems. In training and continuing education on the path to becoming a manager, the use of AI to manage complexity is crucial for success.13

 

Conclusion

  • Strategic realignments require a suitable theoretical foundation, innovative approaches, and problem-oriented learning
  • One such foundation is the management theory of complex evolutionary systems
  • A creative phase in the Designing Solutions for Complex Management Problems (DSCMP) approach is the connecting design
  • Innovative education providers play an important role in applying these foundations and approaches within the framework of problem-oriented learning.

 

Literature

[1] Servatius, H.G., Triple Strategic Realignment. In: Competivation Blog, June 7, 2024

[2] Beer, S., Cybernetics and Management, English Universities Press 1959

[3] Parsons, T., The Social System, The Free Press 1951

[4] Ulrich, H., The Enterprise as a Productive Social System, Haupt 1968

[5] von Hayek, F.A., The Constitution of Liberty, University of Chicago Press 1960

[6] Kirsch, W., Seidel, D., van Aaken, D., Evolutionary Organization Theory, Schäffer-Poeschel 2010

[7] Habermas, J., Theory of Communicative Action (2 volumes), Suhrkamp 1984

[8] Gell-Mann, M., The Quark and the Jaguar: From the Simple to the Complex, Piper 1994, p. 53

[9] Stacey, R.D., Complex Responsive Processes in Organizations – Learning and Knowledge Creation, Routledge 2001

[10] Servatius, H.G., Learning from Successful Digital Companies. In: Competivation Blog, July 12, 2024

[11] Servatius, H.G., Designing Innovative Stakeholder Ecosystems. In: Competivation Blog, January 10, 2023

[12] Servatius, H.G., AI and the Future of Management Education. In: Competivation Blog, April 9, 2025

[13] Knees, L., Maier-Brost, H., How secure is my job from AI? In: Handelsblatt, July 4/5/6, 2025, pp. 54-55

Interessiert?

CONNECTIVE MANAGEMENT

Vereinbaren Sie einen unverbindlichen Gesprächstermin:

 














    +49 (0)211 454 3731