How AI is changing management consulting | Competivation

For decades, the global success of management consulting has been based on identifying new challenges early on and developing solutions that are both theoretically sound and practical. Artificial intelligence (AI) is one such challenge that is also fundamentally changing the consulting industry itself. Starting with an explanation of this evolution, I explore the implications it has for management theory and research.

In this new article, I examine the impact of artificial intelligence on the evolution of management consulting. At the same time, universities and business schools are facing a profound change, which our network of experts has investigated.

 

Management consulting as a career accelerator

For a long time, working at one of the leading consulting firms was considered an important step toward an accelerated career in management. In particular, the major strategy firms hired candidates with strong analytical and communication skills who were able to contribute to solving complex problems and support their implementation. A consulting career typically began with several busy years of research and preparing presentations, which were critically evaluated by project managers. Through this learning process, young consultants developed skills that universities had not taught them.1 Today, AI models handle a significant portion of this work, operating at breathtaking speed, at comparatively low cost, and with surprisingly good results. The world of consulting has changed.

 

Key factors and consequences of the evolution of traditional management consulting

Traditional management consulting is currently undergoing what is arguably the most significant evolution of the past decades. The catalyst for this change is artificial intelligence.2 An examination of the causes points to the following four key factors:

  1. Potential growth for consulting firms offering clients the value proposition of “competitive advantages in the AI era”
  2. Clients undergoing restructuring processes who are struggling to successfully implement an AI strategy
  3. Cooperation between consultants with more relevant experience and in-house AI agents, as well as
  4. AI developers who are not only partners of the consulting firms but are increasingly becoming their competitors as well.

These key factors lead to further consequential effects.

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

The value proposition for clients and their internal challenges create a need for consultants to provide clients with more training. For example, in 2024, Accenture acquired Udacity, a provider of Massive Open Online Courses (MOOCs), and realigned its business model more toward B2B.

Since billing by the hour is no longer appropriate when using in-house AI agents, pricing is becoming more outcome-oriented. However, it is not easy to determine who is ultimately responsible for unsatisfactory results and what the reasons for them are.

As routine tasks are increasingly taken over by AI for clients and consulting firms, both are faced with the question of whether they should hire fewer entry-level professionals. This is changing organizational structures and skill profiles. But the people with AI experience that firms are seeking are also finding interesting opportunities elsewhere.

In addition, major developers of AI models—who in recent years have gone from being partners of consulting firms to their competitors—are increasingly relying on Forward Deployed Engineering (FDE), a methodology developed at Palantir, when implementing AI strategies. This is resulting in a loss of revenue in the growing AI consulting segment to very well-capitalized new competitors who are seeking to create a lock-in effect among corporate clients.3

Compounding these factors is the fact that we are currently witnessing the transition to a new era of management.

 

Transition to a new era of management

Throughout the history of consulting, there have been several transitions to new or significantly altered management eras. For me personally, it was particularly formative to witness how the market- and finance-oriented strategic management of the early 1980s gave rise to a second stage of development that was more strongly focused on technological innovations.4

During these phases of transition, visionary researchers and consulting pioneers often outpace current management practices. This can lead to innovative consultants having difficulty conveying their ideas to clients for a time. As a result, these consultants are always on the lookout for thought leaders on the client side. Problems arise when there is a shortage of thought leaders and trailblazers in a given country.

There are currently significant challenges in implementing AI strategies. In addition to obvious causes, these implementation difficulties are compounded by deeper-rooted and more fundamental issues. Many companies clearly face problems such as

  • a lack of a data foundation and data silos
  • no trustworthy AI infrastructure
  • a shortage of qualified specialists and executives, as well as
  • internal and regulatory hurdles.

As part of a further development of the management practices used to date, it should be possible to overcome these challenges. The situation is different when it comes to fundamental problems. Mastering them marks the transition to a new era of management.

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

Characteristics of this emerging next stage include a new management theory and hybrid organizational concepts.

As early as 1954 and 1969, Peter Drucker shaped an entire era with his groundbreaking publications on Management by Objectives (MbO) and the knowledge society.5 At the heart of a new theory lies connective strategic management (Strategy 5.0), with leaders who orchestrate both people and AI agents.6 In parallel, hybrid organizations are emerging with structures, processes, and projects based on the co-evolution of human capabilities and AI.

The necessary realignment toward a corresponding Management Education 5.0 for the AI era is a fundamental challenge that Germany must overcome.7 There is a strong tendency toward inertia here, and disruption in management education and training is, at best, only beginning to emerge.8

 

Changes in management theory and research on AI

Traditional business administration programs essentially teach the theoretical foundations for entry-level positions. This is due, among other things, to the fact that university professors are primarily academically qualified. When they are appointed, the focus is on publications in top-tier journals rather than on experience outside the academic world. Consequently, at prestigious consulting firms, it typically takes another three “years of apprenticeship” before a consultant with top grades and a Ph.D. is promoted to project manager. This raises the question of the implications for educational providers if, in management consulting and beyond—in the business world in general—not only are many entry-level positions being eliminated due to AI, but the required qualifications are also changing at all hierarchical levels.

For example, a study by the online platform Indeed shows that the number of entry-level positions has fallen by more than two-thirds between the boom year of 2022 and the fall of 2026. The decline was particularly sharp in marketing, at 75 percent.9 Alongside the economic downturn, AI is a major driver of this trend.

Both management consulting firms and their clients have a strong interest in recruiting candidates from universities who are better prepared for the AI era. There are at least three reasons for this:

  1. Newly hired consultants coming straight from college should be able to work on this new type of consulting project without extensive training
  2. Consulting firms, whose revenue depends more heavily on the success of cooperative project work, need clients with broad AI expertise—expertise they can only partially develop from external sources—and
  3. If AI developers and consultants use the “Forward Deployed Engineering” approach—originated at Palantir—when implementing their clients’ strategies, this results in a systematic outflow of knowledge from the client to the service provider, which weakens the client’s competitiveness in the medium term. This cannot be in the client’s best interest.

In management theory and research on AI, a fundamental shift therefore appears necessary, encompassing the following four areas of action:

  1. Expanding university faculty to include AI practitioners
  2. executive development aimed at orchestrating people and AI agents within a hybrid organization
  3. aligning course content and teaching methods with the solving of complex problems and new, AI-oriented career profiles
  4. expanding design-oriented management research on AI topics conducted in real-world laboratories of change.

There are role models both abroad and in Germany that have taken the initiative to drive such a transformation.

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

For decades, there has been a tension in management theory and research between scientific rigor and practical relevance. At U.S. business schools, a stronger scientific orientation began in the late 1950s with the help of quantitative empirical research. This approach was adopted by German universities. In the U.S., however, a pragmatic reorientation toward a “both-and” approach took place much earlier than in Germany, driven by market pressures. At high-cost elite universities, for example, renowned practitioners (Professors of Practice) complement the academic faculty. In the age of artificial intelligence, this mixed staffing structure is gaining importance worldwide.10 Anyone who invests a substantial sum in an MBA program wants that business school to prepare its students—both theoretically and practically—for a job market that is undergoing dramatic change due to AI. Universities in Germany are now also striving for such a realignment. Overall, however, there is a relatively strong tendency here to cling to the status quo.

The starting point for change is often executive development in general and company-specific (customized) Executive MBA programs. Today, aspiring executives must learn how to successfully orchestrate hybrid teams composed of people and AI agents. Interestingly, in a Financial Times ranking of customized executive development programs aimed at corporate realignment, European universities such as SDA Bocconi (Milan), London Business School, and IMD (Lausanne) occupy the top spots. U.S. business schools such as MIT, Stanford, and Wharton score highly for their expertise in AI technologies.

Furthermore, in many fields, it is crucial to improve the ability to solve complex problems and to develop skills for new job profiles. Only a few universities are prepared for this kind of reskilling. However, this is critical to Europe’s efforts to catch up in the field of AI. The necessary impetus for a corresponding realignment of course content and teaching methods comes primarily from innovative educational providers and foundations that draw on international best practices.11 The justified Gen Z demonstrations make it clear that the pressure is mounting. Today’s students should learn how to use AI to solve complex problems faster and more effectively. They can then demonstrate this ability in their theses by using AI as a sparring partner—for example, to refine research questions, examine a topic from different angles, and identify gaps. In the old world of consulting, this was one of the basic skills that “consulting trainees” learned. With AI, the whole process has become much simpler, and universities should teach this skill as early as the first semesters.

Another area of focus is design-oriented management research on AI topics. Experts are watching Germany with great interest and expect a stronger integration of engineering knowledge and industrial AI expertise with new management skills. German global market leaders and startups are demonstrating how such research works in real-world laboratories of change. To support this, an innovation policy that overcomes traditional silo thinking must create suitable framework conditions. At the University of Stuttgart, where I have been teaching strategy and organization since the 1980s, we have long been practicing this research approach within the framework of technically oriented business administration.12 Personally, I have always found teaching and research to be very enriching, alongside leadership positions in management consulting. However, it is time for Germany to better institutionalize this dual role.

 

Conclusion

  • Artificial intelligence is leading to a fundamental change of both the business model and organizational structure of management consulting firms, as well as the relevant competencies of consultants
  • This evolution is taking place as we transition into a new era of management, in which executives will, for the first time, orchestrate both people and AI agents. This requires new approaches to management education
  • For a number of reasons, both management consulting firms and their clients have a vested interest in universities better preparing students for the AI era
  • To achieve this, universities must make their education and research more practice-oriented and more design-oriented. In doing so, they must overcome forces of inertia.

 

References

[1] Kiechel, W., The Lords of Strategy – The Secret Intellectual History of the New Corporate World, Harvard Business Press 2010

[2] Duncan, D.S., Anderson, T., Saviano, J., AI is Changing the Structure of Consulting Firms. In: Harvard Business Review, September 10, 2025

[3] Servatius, H.G., Implementing AI Strategies with a Forward Deployed Engineering approach. In: Competivation Blog, October 29, 2026

[4] Servatius, H.G., Development and change in strategic management. In: Competivation Blog, September 19, 2025

[5] Drucker, P.F., The Practice of Management, Harper 1954, p. 121 ff.

Drucker, P.F., The Age of Discontinuity – Guidelines to Our Changing Society, Heinemann 1969, pp. 247 ff.

[6] Servatius, H.G., Connective strategic management in the age of AI. In: Competivation Blog, May 22, 2026

[7] Servatius, H.G., Management Education 5.0 for Dialog-based Action. In: Competivation Blog, January 13, 2024

[8] Servatius, H.G., Disruption of management education for AI-based realignments. In: Competivation Blog, October 10, 2025

[9] Indeed, Starting a Career Is Getting Harder—Two-Thirds Fewer Entry-Level Jobs Since 2022, but Apprenticeship Positions Are Holding Steady, September 23, 2026

[10] Servatius, H.G., AI and the future of management education. In: Competivation Blog, April 9, 2025

[11] Servatius, H.G., Generative AI and Mass-Customized Action Learning. In: Competivation Blog, August 28, 2023

[12] Servatius, H.G., Design-oriented innovation research on AI applications. In: Competivation Blog, March 25, 2026

Interessiert?

CONNECTIVE MANAGEMENT

Vereinbaren Sie einen unverbindlichen Gesprächstermin:

 














    +49 (0)211 454 3731