Strategy 5.0 | Competivation
Implementing AI strategies with a Forward Deployed Engineering approach

Implementing AI strategies with a Forward Deployed Engineering approach

To date, there have been few satisfactory answers to the question of how established companies can successfully implement an AI strategy. This is surprising, given that nearly all companies must address this question. Possible explanations for this unusual situation lie in the complexity and dynamic nature of the topic. Another reason is that strategy implementation for AI technologies differs from the current state of research on technology strategy. In recent years, our network of experts has tested a general framework for developing and implementing AI strategies using Forward Deployed Engineering (FDE) and has supported companies in adapting it to their specific situations. First, I’d like to briefly address the dual challenge facing many companies.

In this blog post, I’ll explore the significance of the trending topic “Forward Deployed Engineering” in the implementation of AI strategies and why companies should build their own expertise in this area.

 

A dual challenge for companies

The importance of AI strategy for the competitiveness of established companies has increased significantly in recent years.1 However, most companies lack experience in developing and implementing AI strategies.

Furthermore, AI strategies embedded in strategic and organizational realignments often require frequent adjustments. In many cases, these realignments take place during or after a restructuring process using traditional or innovative approaches. Yet the connection between the two challenges—restructuring and realignment—is usually weak. In the context of restructuring, resilience plays an important role in crisis management, and the topic of AI is not a central focus even in current restructuring approaches, such as the Humanocracy concept.

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

In his 2020 book Humanocracy, management guru Gary Hamel described a restructuring approach focused on reducing bureaucracy. Hamel and his co-author criticize hierarchies and advocate for a people-centered organization characterized by seven core principles, such as ownership and openness. In an expanded edition, they also address the topic of AI and argue that bureaucracy hinders the full realization of AI’s potential. Work, they contend, must be reimagined. However, the authors only touch on the exact role AI plays in this context.2

The best-known German company that applies the Humanocracy approach—and has coined the term “Dynamic Shared Ownership” (DSO) to describe it—is Bayer. Under the leadership of Bill Anderson, the chemical and pharmaceutical conglomerate has reduced its 13 hierarchical levels by 50 percent and eliminated two-thirds of its leadership positions. Bayer is not only changing its organizational structure but is also radically implementing the concept of agility. This includes3

  • decentralizing decision-making (shifting 95 percent of decisions directly to units close to customers and products)
  • the creation of entrepreneurial teams (relatively autonomous, cross-functional work groups whose members simultaneously belong to a “professional home”)
  • an iterative work cycle every 90 days (using agile methods), and
  • a new approach to leadership based on the VACC model (Visionary, Architect, Catalyst, Coach).

Agility thus becomes the core of a changed corporate culture. Like many other companies, Bayer is also in the process of realigning itself for the AI era.

A few years ago, we began to structure the evolution of strategic management into stages and to analyze the current fifth stage of connective strategies.4 With this Strategy 5.0, companies face the challenge of a triple realignment, in which they must become more digital, more sustainable, and more resilient.5 When it comes to AI, this temporal connectivity is complemented by vertical connections across various levels—from geopolitics down to individuals—as well as horizontal connections at every level.6 Examples of this can be found in the connectivity of a company’s areas of activity when implementing its AI strategy. Many companies struggle with establishing these connections.

 

Shortcomings in the Implementation of AI Strategies

The IT association Bitkom has determined that the proportion of companies in Germany using AI has risen from 36 to 57 percent within a year. For this study, approximately 600 companies with more than 20 employees were surveyed. Three-quarters of companies use AI to answer questions. However, a third of companies have already developed new products and services with the help of AI. Bitkom therefore concludes that AI has become established in the business world.7 The picture is not as positive when it comes to the implementation of AI strategies.

According to a study published in the first quarter of 2026 by SAP in collaboration with the U.S. market research firm IDC, while 81 percent of the companies surveyed say they have an AI strategy, only 12 to 16 percent have implemented it so far. The study surveyed 620 IT executives in 15 countries. The biggest hurdles to implementation are not infrastructure or data, but a lack of AI expertise, change fatigue, and resistance from employees.8 Therefore, implementing an AI strategy requires an integrated program in which it must be clarified at the outset what the company means by an AI strategy.

 

What is meant by an AI strategy in times of great uncertainty?

The literature on AI strategy offers a multitude of attempted definitions, but these only partially do justice to the dynamic evolution of the topic. In our view, stakeholders with an AI strategy aim to achieve competitive advantages in complex, evolutionary systems.9 These systems are characterized both by the interaction between humans and AI technologies10 as well as by the interaction of actors at various levels (e.g., the level of states and that of organizations). At the organizational level, a traditional distinction is made between actors who develop AI technologies and those who apply them. AI Forward Deployed Engineering connects AI developers with AI users. This definition forms the basis for the concrete formulation of an AI strategy.11

A major factor driving complexity in AI systems today is the fear of losing control. There is considerable uncertainty regarding the questions

  • just how dangerous and autonomous AI technologies can become in a relatively short period of time, and
  • who is responsible for containing potential threats.

This uncertainty stems from the unplanned “outbreaks” of new programs from leading AI companies, which initially hacked their way into other companies’ systems unnoticed. When, for example, Dario Amodei, the CEO of Anthropic, warns that a super-AI could paralyze large parts of the internet and urges that development be slowed down, many experts doubt whether he is truly driven by genuine concern or whether he has other motives.12 It is against this backdrop that European companies are working to catch up in the field of AI.

Yoshua Bengio, a researcher at the University of Montreal in Canada, is a modern AI pioneer who, along with his team, wrote the first paper on how AI models can learn to predict the most likely next word in a text. He has long warned against a loss of control and founded the non-commercial AI company Law Zero in 2025 to develop powerful AI systems that are secure from the ground up. Law Zero is supported by 188 million euros from Canada and Germany and plans to open an office in Berlin. He calls these systems “Scientist AI” because they view the world in a scientific manner, drawing on a vast knowledge base. For safety, it is crucial that this AI adheres to human prohibitions. Such a rule-based approach would strengthen Germany’s bargaining power vis-à-vis the U.S. and China.13

 

Program management for implementing an AI strategy

Based on current experience, the key to successfully implementing an AI strategy lies in designing a program management framework with interconnected areas of action. A key component of this is AI Forward Deployed Engineering (FDE). The term “forward deployed”—originally used in a military context—means that specialists deployed on-site at the customer’s location implement technical systems. The areas of action, which are interconnected through diverse interactions, are:

  1. An AI audit and strategic foresight as the basis for deriving a basic AI strategy
  2. moving from AI pilot projects to AI-based business models
  3. selecting strategic partners with expertise in AI Forward Deployed Engineering
  4. training executives and staff for the AI era
  5. realigning organizations for the co-evolution of human capabilities and agentic AI
  6. designing a new performance management framework for human-AI systems.
Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

Given the dynamic nature of AI technologies, competition, and the political landscape, agility is a key success factor in this program management.

 

AI audit, strategic foresight, and derivation of a basic AI strategy

Companies that take a systematic approach to developing their AI strategy often begin with an AI audit as part of an analysis of their strategic starting point. Following the basic principles of SWOT analysis, they examine the company’s strengths and weaknesses regarding AI, as well as AI-specific opportunities and threats in the environment.

In light of new waves of AI, the topic of strategic foresight is gaining importance. Following the hype surrounding large language models, innovative technologies such as physical AI are now the focus of attention. In addition, artificial intelligence has the potential to accelerate the foresight process itself and enhance its substance. From the results of an AI audit and an AI-supported foresight analysis, basic AI strategies can be derived, such as a focus on increasing productivity, the use of AI for innovation, or a combination of both in the form of AI-based ambidexterity.14

For example, BMW aims to become an AI-orchestrated company by 2028. This refers to the third stage of the evolution of its Operating Model (OM). In the first stage, AI supports employees with individual tasks. The company is currently in the transition to stage two, in which AI agents take over entire processes. In OM 3.0, multiple agents will then collaborate across departmental boundaries. Executive Board member Nicolai Martin considers procurement to be particularly well-suited for this. BMW’s annual procurement volume amounts to 80 billion euros. He aims to save a mid-three-digit million amount using AI agents.15

Instead of such a systematic approach, many companies are experimenting with AI pilot projects that lack a clear underlying strategy.

 

Moving from AI pilot projects to AI-based business models

The danger of uncoordinated, individual AI activities and AI pilot projects is that they create a patchwork that does not lead to lasting value creation. A better approach is a gradual shift toward AI-based business models.

The term “business model” emerged in management theory a quarter-century ago in the wake of the development of e-commerce. The Business Model Canvas, published in 2010 and featuring nine key areas, is widely used to describe and refine business models.16

We have adapted this analytical framework—which, for example, completely excludes the topic of sustainability 17—to the specific characteristics of AI-based business models. Our AI Business Model Canvas has eleven interconnected action areas. In practice, it has proven effective as a method for shaping the dynamic evolution of business models.

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

In many companies, the development journey begins by leveraging the resources of AI partner companies, such as providers of large language models or AI startups and their financial partners. This initial phase is often more experimental than strategic in nature. The result is a multitude of collaborations that are poorly coordinated with one another. A current trend is that AI companies such as OpenAI and Anthropic, as well as software providers like SAP, are adopting “Forward Deployed Engineering”—a concept developed by the U.S. company Palantir—to help their customers better implement their AI strategies.

The initial goal is often AI-driven productivity gains in value-added and customer- processes. A gradual transition is emerging from AI assistants to AI agents that take on specific tasks under human supervision. The aim should be to select strategic AI partners with a clearly defined own strategy, that also takes into account the risks of collaboration.

At the same time, companies face the question of which AI resources they should build in-house. The AI-related spectrum ranges from the technologies and infrastructure used, through a unified database, to the utilization of their own knowledge and the improvement of AI skills.

In addition to existing costs, there are AI-related additional costs, which are increasingly being systematically tracked. However, the hoped-for productivity gains often fail to materialize, which has now led to a sense of disillusionment with AI. As a result, routing models that select the AI technologies offering the best price-performance ratio for the task at hand are gaining importance.

In addition to these resource-oriented strategic approaches, companies are addressing the AI-driven shift in customer behavior. This shift involves not only industry-specific aspects but also a segment-specific component, ranging from early adopters to experienced users.

Artificial intelligence is changing not only customer processes but also customer relationships. It enables greater real-time personalization, quick responses, reactions from agent-based AI bots, and more time for personal customer interaction when dealing with complex tasks. The technical implementation is achieved by integrating AI into Customer Relationship Management (CRM) systems.

This enables AI-based value propositions for customers, featuring price advantages and innovations in products and services. There remains a need for design-oriented management research regarding new AI-based business model patterns. One example is the “Automation as a Service” model. In this regard, established automation specialists such as Siemens are increasingly developing their own expertise in forward-deployed engineering.

The goal is successful growth driven by AI-generated revenue, leading to sustainable value creation. European companies face the challenge of catching up with competitors in the U.S. and China. The integrated approach of the AI Business Model Canvas makes an important contribution in this regard. Compared to traditional canvas models, we have added two areas of action.

The first addresses the impacts of a company’s own AI ecosystem on the environment and society—concepts already familiar from the Sustainable Business Model Canvas. Key topics include, for example, the development of green data centers and the protection of jobs threatened by AI through continuing education.

The second area addresses not only public AI funding but also approaches to AI regulation and protection against the threats posed by AI. These two areas illustrate that artificial intelligence requires a multi-level strategy, which I explained in our last blog post.

 

Selecting strategic partners with expertise in AI Forward Deployed Engineering

When selecting strategic partners, the question arises regarding their performance and trustworthiness.18 This applies in particular to Palantir, a company co-founded in 2003 by the politically controversial U.S. billionaire Peter Thiel and current CEO Alexander Karp, which has further developed its Forward Deployed Engineering (FDE) into AI FDE as part of its AI initiative. Regardless of the political views of these two individuals, it is important to understand the core ideas that have shaped the development of this FDE pioneer.

The current hype surrounding FDE was sparked by an MIT study published in 2025, which concluded that 95 percent of corporate GenAI pilot projects do not deliver the hoped-for economic success. However, according to, the cause of these initiatives’ failure usually lies not in the AI models themselves, but in the gap between the model and its implementation at the customer site.19

The core ideas of Peter Thiel and Alexander Karp, upon which Palantir’s Forward Deployed Engineering is based, are:20

  1. A human-machine symbiosis rather than pure AI automation (Thiel and Karp). The strength of AI lies in structuring large amounts of data. But it takes people with intuition to recognize patterns in complex contexts.
  2. Institutional behavioral theory with the concept of the “anticipatory waiter” (Karp). IT service providers should not be subservient executors who simply work through specifications without understanding the customer’s actual problem. The waiter knows the kitchen procedures (software) just as well as the guest’s (customer’s) preferences. He has enough self-confidence to competently redirect the guest if the guest wants to order something unwise.
  3. Avoiding competition through a unique business model (Thiel). Software as a Service is easy to copy. The true barrier that prevents a switch to another provider (moat) arises where software meets the messy, real world. This is the basis for the concept “from a gravel road to a paved highway.”
  4. Pragmatism in the real world versus abstract theory (Karp). In real life, there are no clean data structures or universally valid IT architectures straight off the drawing board. FDEs are “engineer-diplomats” who must act pragmatically. Perfect code is secondary here. What matters is code that works even in crisis situations.

Palantir’s successful business model is thus the astonishing result of Thiel’s economic theory of monopoly and Karp’s social-scientific understanding of human interactions, in which software—and later AI—is integrated into the customer’s reality.

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

The professional practice (craft) of Forward Deployed Engineering is characterized by the interplay of two roles, which Palantir refers to as Echo and Delta. The Echo role involves diving deep into the client’s organization to identify an often-hidden core problem. This requires strong subject matter and industry expertise. However, the Echo type is not a complacent practitioner but rather a “domain rebel” who recognizes what is currently not working well and identifies the underlying causes. To do this, they must also understand an organization’s culture and the internal politics of departments.

These “what” and “why” questions give rise to requirements for the Delta type. Through iterative learning loops, the Delta type develops functional solutions that do not necessarily have to align exactly with the client’s original expectations. The decisive factor in the “how” is whether the solution ultimately proves itself in the customer’s day-to-day operations. In addition to technical expertise, this requires “jagged” intelligence that takes into account the uneven capability profile of AI. This resembles a cliff landscape with steep peaks (genius) and deep valleys (total failure).

Close collaboration with the client (engagement) in an AI-FDE project is divided into the following three phases:

  1. Scope (requirement definition)
  2. validate (proof of concept) and
  3. deliver (deployment).

The scoping phase focuses on precisely identifying the client’s problem and translating it into a technical AI specification. During validation, the primary question is whether the identified problem is indeed a high priority. If not, the scope is adjusted accordingly. The practical integration of a solution into a client’s infrastructure then takes place during the deliver phase.

Palantir’s concept of “from a gravel road to a paved highway” means that there are two types of solutions in Forward Deployed Engineering. The first is the solution developed at the customer’s site, for which the customer pays (“the gravel road”). From a large number of such customer solutions, the provider generates a systematic learning effect that feeds into its own platform (“the paved highway”) and enables competitive advantages. This effect has long been known in the consulting industry, but it reaches a new dimension with FDE and AI platforms worth billions.

Therefore, when collaborating with FDE providers, customers should weigh

  • the increased speed enabled by the provider
  • the loss of abstract knowledge, which is generated not within the client’s organization but by the provider
  • the increasing dependence on one or more AI platform providers, as well as
  • ongoing usage costs paid to third parties and a lack of in-house expertise for necessary further developments.

Therefore, if the problem to be solved concerns a key competitive advantage, data sovereignty is a top priority, or the goal is long-term cost control and value creation, the company should rely on its own FDE expertise.

For this reason, the responsibility for selecting strategic AI partners and shaping the company’s own human resources strategy lies with the board of directors or executive management (“the CEO”).

In this context, the following three dimensions of a reinterpreted AI performance concept must be taken into account:

  1. The performance of the AI models used
  2. the trustworthiness of strategic AI partners, and
  3. the ratio of AI results to AI costs following the implementation of an initial AI project and in the longer term.

It is not uncommon for a performance paradox to arise, in which the performance of the models varies depending on the task, the trustworthiness of the partners is low, and the long-term cost-benefit ratio is poor.

SAP is taking a different approach than AI developers, who focus on large language models that struggle with numbers. Together with Prior Labs, a Freiburg-based startup it acquired, the company in Walldorf is focusing on adapting tabular models that process data to knowledge-specific business processes. In the case of Forward Deployed Engineering, there is a return to the experiences of the company’s early years. From the perspective of SAP’s Chief Technology Officer Philipp Herzog, the goal is to closely study the behavior of knowledge workers, develop the right AI agents for this purpose, and identify the corresponding patterns that run on the SAP platform.21

Of significant importance to SAP’s AI strategy is its investment in the startup Nova Intelligence, whose founders include Alexander Zeier, who developed SAP HANA together with Hasso Plattner. In most companies, a large portion of the knowledge about how the organization operates is embedded in the SAP system’s accumulated custom code. An agent-based AI platform that modernizes the SAP system must first capture this knowledge. The applications of the coming years will be built on this specific knowledge model of business processes. In the past, the transition to S/4 HANA has taken place in two ways: First, “Greenfield,” in which in-house developments are left behind, and second, “Brownfield,” in which everything that has accumulated is migrated to the new platform. Nova Intelligence has developed a new modernization approach for which the term “Cleanfield” is currently gaining traction. This approach starts with the question of what should be carried over from the existing system and what the company would like to redesign. “Cleanfield” therefore means: first clean up, then convert. Using this approach, a number of companies have already successfully transitioned to S/4 HANA and agent-based AI.22

An important role in the realignment of SAP and its customers is played by training for the new tasks.

 

Training Executives and staff for the AI era

Given the risk that the hype surrounding Forward Deployed Engineering (FDE) primarily benefits large AI developers, the question arises as to what a training initiative would need to look like to ensure that FDE becomes a core competency for as many AI users as possible.23

So far, there are only a few pioneers among AI-using companies that are breaking new ground in workforce development. Since the market for FDEs has been swept clean, companies such as Siemens, Mercedes-Benz, Bayer, and Allianz are relying on internal upskilling programs. Key objectives include

  • the development of a “build-to-learn” culture
  • training subject matter experts for the Echo and Delta roles, as well as
  • the development of in-house AI platforms to safeguard competencies critical to success.

At the same time, it would be important to improve the education and training of FDEs as part of a European multi-level AI strategy. Such an educational initiative requires targeted linkages between traditional IT, engineering, and management degree programs that prepare students for new professional roles—such as that of the FDE—not only theoretically but also practically. These linkages would be of great importance to small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), with their numerous “hidden champions,” whose expertise should not be siphoned off to digital giants.

Unfortunately, such an educational policy initiative has so far only begun to take shape. However, it also opens up opportunities for teaching and research at universities that are willing to take advantage of these possibilities. In the work of our expert network, we combine transdisciplinary, practice-oriented teaching with design-oriented management research and consulting.24

The ontology of an AI platform plays an important role in this context. The term “ontology,” coined by the German philosopher Jacob Lorhard as early as 1606, originally described the study of being. In 1993, the U.S. computer scientist Tom Gruber applied this concept to AI research. Here, ontology—in the sense of specifying a conceptualization—forms the foundation for platforms. An AI platform ontology is defined as the formal, machine-readable description of a subject area (domain) within an AI environment. It defines which entities (e.g., customers and products), properties, relationships, and logical rules exist. As a result, the ontology functions as a kind of standardized knowledge map that translates unstructured corporate data into a consistent, overarching semantic model.25

The significance of such an AI platform ontology for continuing education in companies that use AI lies in the fact that the ontology acts as a translator between human business language and technical AI logic. This not only changes, for example, onboarding and relevant prompting skills, but it also creates a need for employees from specialized departments to be trained as “ontology managers.” Their task is to maintain the ontology and continuously feed it with new domain knowledge. Since this activity secures competitive advantages, companies should not outsource it to external parties.

Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella describes the current asymmetry between AI users and AI developers as a “reverse information paradox.” By this, he means a one-way street of knowledge in which power and knowledge dynamics shift in favor of the AI developer, while the AI user relies on the developer’s models.26

The AI developer does not train their AI models using publicly available data from the internet. They also learn from the user’s “intelligence- exhaust” with every interaction. At the same time, they prohibit the user from learning from the AI’s responses in order to improve their own model (model distillation).

On the other hand, the user not only pays once to use the developer’s AI model, but also a second time through the internal knowledge that flows to the developer. As a result, the user continuously loses competitiveness. Nadella recommends countermeasures based on five principles. These include maintaining control over one’s own data, training the models in-house, ensuring developers have freedom of choice, and combining models. The goal of combining these principles is to improve one’s own AI resources.

While Nadella’s provocative assessment has met with broad approval in Europe, small and medium-sized enterprises in particular are finding it difficult to implement these countermeasures. Furthermore, it’s important to recognize that Microsoft has not only invested billions in OpenAI but also profits from AI model developers through its Azure cloud platform.

An important question, therefore, is whether companies using AI will succeed in mastering the emerging organizational realignments through a training initiative.

 

AI-Driven Organizational Realignment and Changes in Performance Management

There are interesting developments in the AI-based realignment of organizations and changes in performance management, which I plan to discuss in my next articles. However, the situation here is somewhat unclear, so it is not entirely obvious which new trends will prevail in practice. The interplay between AI-based strategic and organizational realignments—and their implications for a fundamental shift in how goals are derived and how the performance of humans and AI agents is measured—plays a key role in this context.

 

Conclusion

  • Many companies say they now have an AI strategy, but are struggling to implement it
  • One of the reasons for these difficulties is a high degree of uncertainty regarding potential threats posed by AI technologies
  • Implementing an AI strategy requires program management with interconnected areas of action
  • The transition from AI pilot projects to AI-based business models is supported by an AI Business Model Canvas as a framework for business model evolution
  • Many AI developers now rely on “Forward Deployed Engineering,” a methodology developed at Palantir that is based on several core ideas and distinguishes between two roles and three phases
  • It is risky for AI users that their knowledge systematically flows to the AI developers, giving the latter a competitive advantage
  • In the professional development of AI users, understanding their own company’s AI platform ontology is becoming increasingly important.

 

References

[1] Servatius, H.G., Competitive Advantages with Knowledge-Based AI. In: Competivation Blog, February 11, 2025

[2] Hamel, G., Zanini, M., Humanocracy – Creating Organizations as Amazing as the People Inside Them, Updated and Expanded, Harvard Business Review Press 2025

[3] Viel, O., Dynamic Shared Ownership – How Bayer Is Rewiring the Enterprise for Agility, Purpose, and AI Readiness, July 24, 2025

[4] Servatius, H.G., Strategy 5.0 for Tackling New Challenges. In: Competivation Blog, June 28, 2022

[5] Servatius, H.G., Triple Strategic Realignment. In: Competivation Blog, June 7, 2024

[6] Servatius, H.G., Innovation Narratives for a Connective Multi-Level AI Strategy. In: Competivation Blog, September 9, 2026

[7] Mensch, T., AI Success Depends on Management. In: Handelsblatt, October 13, 2026, p. 26

[8] Misra, S., Most Companies Have an AI Strategy. What the Top 8% Do Differently. In: SAP Website, May 8, 2026

[9] Servatius, H.G., Connecting Causal AI with Complex Evolutionary Systems. In: Competivation Blog, August 13, 2026

[10] Servatius, H.G., Connective Strategic Management in the Age of AI. In: Competivation Blog, May 22, 2026

[11] Servatius, H.G., Development of AI Technologies. In: Competivation Blog, February 19, 2025

[12] Alvarez de Souza Soarez, M. et al., The World in the Grip of AI. In: Handelsblatt, September 18, 19, and 20, 2026, pp. 6–12

[13] Bengio, Y., “These AIs Cheat, Even Though They’re Not Supposed To” (Interview). In: Handelsblatt, September 25, 26, and 27, 2026, pp. 38–39

[14] Servatius, H.G., AI as a Tool for Strategic Management. In: Competivation Blog, May 1, 2025

[15] Bomke, L., Stippler, F., AI Business Model Expected to Save BMW Billions. In: Handelsblatt, October 17, 2026, pp. 26–27

[16] Osterwalder, A., Pigneur, Y., Business Model Generation – A Handbook for Visionaries, Game Changers, and Challengers, John Wiley & Sons, 2010

[17] Servatius, H.G., Sustainable Business Models Through Improved Stakeholder Interaction. In: Competivation Blog, April 11, 2018

[18] Servatius, H.G., Designing Trustworthy High-Performance Systems. In: Competivation Blog, January 29, 2026

[19] Goldmann, S., MIT Report – 95% of Generative AI Initiatives at Companies Are Failing. In: Fortune, August 18, 2025

[20] Gramatikov, R., Forward Deployed – Inside the Palantir Framework that Solved Enterprise AI, Amazon Digital Services, 2026

[21] Alvarez de Souza Soares, P., Kerkmann, C., How SAP Plans to Win Again Despite Lagging Behind in AI. In: Handelsblatt, October 5, 2026, pp. 24–25

[22] Zeier, A., Agent-Based AI Is Changing the Economics of SAP Systems. In: E3 Supplement, November 2026, pp. 10–21

[23] Servatius, H.G., Disruption in Management Education of AI-Based Realignments. In: Competivation Blog, October 29, 2025

[24] Seratius, H.G., Design-oriented Innovation Research on AI Applications. In: Competivation Blog, March 25, 2026

[25] Talisman, J., Ontology Pipeline – A Framework for Building Knowledge Infrastructures, Technics Publications 2026

[26] Nadella, S., The Reverse Information Paradox. In: Platform X, July 12, 2026

Innovation narratives for a connective multi-level AI strategy

Innovation narratives for a connective multi-level AI strategy

When it comes to Artificial Intelligence (AI), Europe faces the challenge of catching up with the U.S. and China. This requires a connective, multi-level strategy spanning from the macro level of geopolitics through the micro level of companies to the level of individuals. An important foundation of this strategy is the plurality of innovation narratives addressing various aspects of the catch-up process. This approach represents an extension of the fifth stage of connective strategic management that we have described thus far.

In this new blog post, I explore how innovation narratives can help Europe gain a competitive edge in Artificial Intelligence through a connective multi-level strategy.

 

Search for innovation narratives on Artificial Intelligence

AI experts argue that Germany’s future as a hub for AI depends on closer collaboration between academia and industry. A long-standing problem has been the translation of research findings into market-ready products and services.1 The political framework and people’s mindsets also play a decisive role. To overcome pessimism about the future and unite the efforts of all stakeholders, compelling innovation narratives are needed. A current topic in this context is Artificial Intelligence.

The term “narrative” describes a meaningful story that appeals to the emotions of a target audience and guides their actions. This classic definition requires a nuanced examination.

In his 1979 book The Postmodern Condition: A Report on Knowledge, the French philosopher Jean-François Lyotard critically examines the idea of a narrative as a grand story. These meta-narratives of modernity—such as the enlightenment or capitalism—served primarily to provide political and philosophical justification for domination, science, and social norms. Following the catastrophes of the 20th century, these meta-narratives are said to have lost their credibility and unifying power. In postmodernism, they are replaced by small narratives. These micro-narratives are characterized by a limited scope and a local context, based on knowledge-specific language games. A defining feature of postmodernism is a multitude of coexisting narratives that complement and contradict one another and shape life in a pluralistic world.2

Lyotard’s approach is visionary for our current understanding of innovation narratives, as he anticipated as early as 1979 the positive and negative effects of the AI era, with its mechanisms and ruptures. A core concept in his book is the performativity of a postmodern world in which grand truths are absent and systems are designed according to the principle of maximum optimization. However, this perspective tends to be rather critical of technology and underestimates the potential benefits arising from innovations.

The search for innovation narratives on artificial intelligence should therefore take threats seriously in order to generate positive effects. Put neutrally, an innovation narrative is a strategic story that explains the purpose of an innovation. These innovations may appear desirable, but they are often associated with threats as well. Therefore, skepticism toward one-sided grand narratives seems appropriate. One challenge lies in the plurality of micro-narratives, among which complex interactions are possible.

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

Threats posed by AI technologies are, first and foremost, existential risks such as job loss, loss of control, and the eradication of human identity. Added to this is a competence paradox, in which technological developments outpace human adaptability. Of increasing importance are the distortion of truth and social division, which manifest in targeted disinformation and the reinforcement of prejudices. This leads to wake-up calls demanding better regulation and viewing human-in-the-loop.

Narratives that emphasize the positive effects of artificial intelligence therefore continue to place humans at the center. AI is merely a co-pilot that relieves humans of routine tasks and enhances human capabilities. This creates economic opportunities and leads to competitive advantages through increased productivity and leadership in innovation, but it also requires new job profiles. In addition, environmental and societal benefits arise from better management of complex problems such as climate change and the democratization of autocracies. Key foundations for this are responsibility and trust, which form an ethical basis, create security, facilitate public participation, and ultimately ensure independence from enemies of our democratic order.

The search for innovation narratives from which Europe can learn in preparation for the next waves of AI leads, for example, to Canada.

 

Learning from Canada in preparation for the next waves of AI

Key impetus for the development of AI in Canada has come from Geoffrey Hinton, a Nobel laureate in physics. This includes

  • decades of work on neural networks at the University of Toronto, which gave him the freedom and necessary financial support to pursue this topic—which was less popular in the 1980s and 1990s
  • the establishment of a national research network in collaboration with other AI pioneers
  • the integration of cutting-edge research with the Canadian business community, and
  • the launch of the world’s first national AI strategy in 2017.

As a result, Canada has become a global magnet for talent. In 2023, Hinton ended his collaboration with Google and shifted his focus more toward AI safety. He used the prominence he gained from winning the Nobel Prize in 2024 to warn of the dangers of uncontrolled AI.3

Through its innovation program Next AI, the national nonprofit organization NEXT Canada aims to support promising founders from the idea stage through to market readiness in order to expand Canada’s leadership role in AI. The program is based on a multi-level strategy. This consists of

  • a geographic level for the Toronto and Montreal regions
  • a complementary business cycle level for innovation teams in these leading AI regions, and
  • integration into the national AI strategy.

The key is a well-coordinated connection of these levels. Given the success of this approach, Europe should focus more intensively on the development and implementation of multi-level strategies. One example of the next wave is Physical AI.

 

The example of Physical AI

According to Robin Rombach, co-founder of the Freiburg-based AI startup Black Forest Lab (BFL), a new technological wave is currently emerging that opens up new opportunities for European companies. This involves AI systems that understand and interact with the physical world (Physical AI). Europe’s strengths include a relatively large number of AI researchers, a number of top universities and research institutions, and the diversity of industrial applications in which AI helps solve real-world problems and realign industries. European startups, which are now achieving valuations in the billions, are capitalizing on these opportunities with domain-specific AI models that build on their own research activities and are competitive on a global scale. However, a significant portion of the venture capital for these startups still comes from the U.S. In addition, major U.S. technology conglomerates are investing billions in data centers there. These benefit from fast approvals and low energy costs.4

AI-based robotics is emerging as a new growth market. Experts expect the global robotics market to grow to $2.5 trillion by 2035—25 times its current level. China has recognized this potential and is pursuing a clear strategy. The country is already by far the largest market and is driving the development of highly automated production structures that operate without human labor (“dark factories”). Unitree, a company based in Hangzhou in eastern China, is the first manufacturer of humanoid robots to be publicly traded on the mainland Chinese stock market. Since geopolitical tensions with the U.S. have escalated, the Chinese government has been encouraging companies to list on the domestic market rather than in New York.5

Artificial intelligence is increasingly being used in end devices, such as in cars, where it optimizes driving behavior, or in logistics robots. This decentralized edge AI is a subset of physical AI. While Nvidia chips dominate in data centers, edge AI relies on semiconductors from the Dutch company NXP, for example. These must be energy-efficient and have a long service life. European suppliers are global leaders in this field. The decentralization of AI also opens up new opportunities for end-device manufacturers.6

 

Model router for selecting the right AI

Alongside new technologies, a cost-benefit analysis of AI is becoming increasingly important. This is because the more AI-powered products companies use, the higher their consumption of computing units (tokens)—which AI providers use to bill customers. In light of rising AI costs, customers are increasingly asking what benefits AI provides and whether they need to use the particularly expensive “frontier” models from the U.S. for all applications. High token consumption (tokenmaxxing) does not automatically lead to greater efficiency. For less complex tasks, open-weight models—which are pre-trained and can be run by a company on its own servers—are often sufficient. The Berlin-based startup Langdock and other providers have developed routing platforms that analyze tasks and forward them to the most suitable AI. Customers’ nuanced cost-benefit analysis poses a challenge for AI providers such as Anthropic and OpenAI in light of their planned initial public offerings (IPOs).7

Model routers are giving rise to a new billion-dollar market driven by companies’ need to get AI costs under control. Chip giant Nvidia is also entering the router business; with Nemo Switchyard, it has introduced a system that automates model selection. The Düsseldorf-based startup Kauz AI is specifically targeting customers in Europe with its router business. In addition to cost, the Kauz Selection product focuses on data sovereignty. The advantage of specialized router providers is that they constantly adapt their products to the rapidly changing model landscape. Chinese providers are also trying to capitalize on this advantage. Overall, all providers aim to give customers more power again.8

Disruption driven by AI with a better price-performance ratio is also coming from the Beijing-based startup Moonshot. Its new open-weight model, Kimi K3, achieves very good results without relying on the scaling law or the illusion that more data and computing power always lead to better results. For founder Yang Zhilin, token efficiency is the top priority. To this end, Moonshot combines the following four approaches:

  1. A distinction between less important information and important information stored for longer periods, which requires less storage space and enables faster responses (Delta Attention)
  2. The targeted processing of information from previous layers (Attention Residuals), which results in less diluted outcomes
  3. a multitude of specialized networks (Mixture of Experts), which enables more precise access to information, as well as
  4. the decomposition of a query into small subtasks and parallel processing by individual agent systems (Agent Swarm).

This example shows that AI competition among economic regions has become even fiercer.9 This is where multilevel strategies come into play.

 

Multi-level strategies as the third dimension of connectivity

Over the past few decades, several approaches to multi-level strategies have emerged, though they employ different classifications and definitions of the levels. The basic principle of a multi-level strategy was already described in the mid-1990s by Richard Whittington of the Said Business School at the University of Oxford in his “Strategy-as-Practice” concept.10 Dutch transition research, building on the work of Frank Geels, has also been pursuing a multi-level approach since the early 2000s.11 The fourth generation of the St. Gallen Management Model (SGMM) distinguishes between different levels in terms of perspectives.12 Also of interest is the “Microfoundations of Strategy” approach, which advocates an aggregation from the individual level upward.13

In light of numerous new challenges, our framework distinguishes between the macro level (geopolitics and the environment), the meso level (nations and regions), the micro level (companies and public administrations), as well as society and individuals. We refer to the links between these levels as vertical connectivity.

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

Connective design also plays an important role in multi-level strategies. We discussed this capability in a publication on the development and evolution of strategic management.14 The focus here is on the temporal connectivity linking the five stages of strategic management identified to date. Horizontal connectivity within a single level also always plays an important role. Examples include a country’s various policy areas or the fields of action and actors within a company’s innovation system.15 The following figure illustrates these three dimensions of connectivity.

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

One cause of shortcomings in connectivity is increasing dynamism and complexity. In an environment that has become more dynamic, companies with traditional hierarchies and silo structures struggle to tackle complex problems. Parallel to this vertical connectivity, horizontal connectivity poses a challenge for many organizations when implementing IT- and AI-supported process management.16 Horizontal connectivity also poses difficulties between organizations. One example is the transfer of technology from universities to established companies via startups. In the context of strategic realignments—such as those related to the energy and mobility transitions—, vertical connectivity between organizations has proven to be a bottleneck. This highlights the need for improved forms of collaboration. This applies to politics, academia, and the business sector in general. Fraunhofer President Holger Hanselka calls for the removal of bureaucratic hurdles throughout the entire innovation pathway.17

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

The goal of multi-level strategies is to address threats and generate positive effects. I would like to illustrate this with examples, starting at the macro level with geopolitics and the environment.

 

From geopolitics to regions

Geopolitics forms the highest, framework-setting level that shapes global rules and strategic alliances. A primary role is ensuring technological sovereignty. The goal here is to reduce dependencies and protect one’s own infrastructure. A regulatory competition over global standards is underway between the U.S., China, and Europe. Geopolitical bloc formation and trade barriers—such as export controls—play a significant role in this context. National security and cyber defense are becoming increasingly important in the context of asymmetric warfare. Global bodies are vying for interpretive authority and standardization, for example, of technical protocols.18 Currently, the U.S. government and tech companies accuse China of training its AI models using U.S. technologies (knowledge distillation). The Chinese Ministry of Commerce denies this.19

The negative environmental impacts of AI are also of geopolitical significance. These include the high electricity consumption required for training and operating large AI models, CO₂ emissions when electricity comes from fossil fuels, the enormous water consumption needed to cool servers, electronic waste from rapidly obsolescent hardware, and resource consumption—for example, in the mining of rare earth elements. In the U.S., there are already protests against the construction of new, massive data centers. Individual states are enacting comprehensive new AI laws. Public sentiment is shifting. 71 percent of Americans oppose a data center in their neighborhood.20 Green data centers—operating in cooler regions with renewable energy and closed-loop water systems—could offer a solution.

At the meso-level of nations and regions, the question arises of how Germany, together with other countries, can catch up with the U.S. and China in the field of AI. This requires a series of coordinated strategic programs, such as

  • a focus on AI applications that require specific capabilities
  • intensive collaboration between established companies and AI startups, with their growth funded more heavily from Europe
  • scaling up trustworthy AI infrastructure
  • a realignment of AI education and training, as well as
  • the use of innovation-friendly regulation as a competitive advantage.

It remains to be seen how many European providers of large language models there should be. In Japan, the startup Sakana AI is attempting to reduce this dependence. To this end, it is working with a system in which various models are embedded. It functions similarly to a conductor coordinating a swarm of agents. Such orchestration also presents an opportunity for Europe.21 The diversity of the regions can be an advantage in this regard.

Hidden champions play a key role in regional AI development by serving as practical partners for research institutes. Therefore, these lesser-known global market leaders act as

  • data providers for specific AI
  • investors in sustainability-focused impact startups
  • drivers of regional AI ecosystems, and
  • magnets for tech talent.

In this way, hidden champions not only improve their own competitiveness but also strengthen the financial strength of local communities. One example is the sensor specialist ifm electronic, headquartered in Essen with a production site at Tettnang on Lake Constance. The company has evolved from a sensor manufacturer into an AI platform for production. The importance of hidden champions for regional development has long been recognized, but their potential role as AI pioneers has yet to be fully explored. This is currently giving rise to exciting new narratives.22

 

From companies to individuals

At the micro level of companies and public administration, we must address the question of why established organizations find AI-based change so difficult. The challenge likely lies in integrating a range of areas of action. These include

  • a strategy for realigning business models
  • overcoming cultural and personnel barriers
  • developing AI competencies from the executive level through middle management down to entry-level employees
  • designing a high-performance AI infrastructure in collaboration with trusted partners, as well as
  • integrating individual pilot projects into a coordinated process of changing organizations.

Despite the widespread use of the buzzword “digital transformation,” the number of organizations that have successfully achieved this level of change is limited.23

One success story is the Swabian family-owned company Trumpf, which ranks among the global market leaders in the use of lasers for sheet metal processing and chip manufacturing. The company is working on a new stage of development in AI-supported robotics for sheet metal processing. For example, in the SortMaster Vision, AI uses cameras to analyze the position of sheet metal parts to be processed and calculates a spatial image of the situation, which facilitates the sorting process. In doing so, the AI continuously learns from real-world data without the need for extensive reprogramming. Trumpf aims to take a leading role in AI applications in production. This example demonstrates how important it is to combine specific knowledge with AI expertise. Other organizations can learn from this.24

So far, public administration in Germany has fared even worse than the private sector in mastering the digital change. Yet we could have learned from the small Baltic state of Estonia. Around 2000, the “Government-as-a-Platform” concept emerged there. Under this concept, the government provides a platform on which all services are built. It defines standards and guarantees security and functionality. The X-Road data pipeline, which originated from an open-source project, is based on this concept. The basic idea was that data would remain decentralized within individual organizations but could still circulate. This has become a major export success, deployed by the company Cybernetica as a service provider in more than 20 countries. Germany is not among them because, here, there have long been plans to develop a next generation that is even better.25

The current German Minister for Digital Affairs is planning a unified framework consisting of standards, software, and infrastructure. This “Deutschland-Stack” is intended to streamline government agencies. However, the plan faces challenges from existing specialized procedures and software architectures. The “Deutschland-App” is set to be the first visible product for citizens.26  Critics describe it as nothing more than “window-dressing digitalization.” They argue that the challenge lies not in the app itself, but in the processes behind it. The outcome of a pilot project remains to be seen.27

More generally, the question arises as to what implications AI has for society in an industrialized country like Germany. In light of a multitude of crises, these implications primarily concern the transition of the world of work. Here, there is a risk of a societal divide between a few winners who capitalize on the opportunities created by AI and a multitude of losers whose jobs are eliminated or changed in ways that leave them unable to withstand this pressure. Populists are exploiting this development to capitalize on polarization. This makes it all the more important to intensify AI-oriented education and training as a counterbalance to strengthen societal resilience. The everyday experiences of people who recognize how AI helps them—for example, with legal and medical issues—can play a significant role in this regard. Overall, better cooperation across various policy areas appears necessary to prepare for this change process.28

In the world of work, major upheavals are on the horizon for individuals at all hierarchical levels. This applies above all to management. For those just entering the workforce, routine tasks—which AI is taking over—are becoming less important. It is becoming increasingly relevant to acquire knowledge on how to work with AI already during one’s training. In middle management and at the top level, the competencies required for personnel management are changing in particular. Personal experience with AI strategies and AI-driven productivity gains has now become a prerequisite for leadership positions. In this context, AI takes on the role of a sparring partner. The upheavals caused by AI are occurring at a time when companies are already streamlining hierarchical levels and cutting jobs. This contributes to a sense of uncertainty. An important task for the remaining executives is to tap into AI-based productivity potential and use the freed-up capacity to create something new. An innovation narrative should emphasize this positive aspect.29

Customers of OCBC Bank in Singapore have recently been able to discuss their portfolios with an avatar. Nevertheless, the bank has no plans to cut staff; rather, it aims to expand its workforce to continue growing. In this regard, the OCBC CEO is in line with the Singaporean government, which wants to be among the global pioneers in the use of AI but at the same time seeks to ensure that the AI-driven realignment of the financial sector does not result in massive job losses. To this end, there is a pact between the government, financial institutions, and the labor union. At its core is a continuing education and retraining program designed to equip employees for new roles. At Singapore’s leading bank, all 40,000 employees have now received basic AI training, and 11,000 have been qualified for new roles created by the use of AI. Singapore’s Institute of Banking and Finance (IBF) plays a leading role in continuing education.30

 

A connective effect despite threats?

An examination of potential innovation narratives at various levels reveals a diverse picture overall. This raises the question of how these narratives can exert a connective effect within the framework of a multi-level AI strategy, even though AI poses significant threats.

We have seen that, at the macro level, geopolitics is primarily concerned with AI supremacy and reducing dependencies through digital sovereignty. AI can have negative environmental impacts, as is the case, for example, with large data centers. This underscores the importance of green AI.

At the meso level of the nations, Germany faces the challenge of catching up with the U.S. and China through a series of coordinated AI programs. In the different regions, the numerous hidden champions, with their specific application expertise, should take on a leading role.

At the micro level, established companies in particular must identify the root causes of their challenges in digital change and find appropriate solutions to address them. It remains to be seen whether the new approaches to digitizing public administration in Germany will be successful. In any case, we can learn from other countries.

The serious implications of AI for society require new forms of resilience to reduce the risk of social division. For each individual—especially those in management roles—work is undergoing fundamental changes at all hierarchical levels. These points are summarized in the following figure.

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

When addressing the question of the connecting effect despite potential threats, a key insight is that micro-narratives can have both positive and negative manifestations. The connectivity is amplified when positive manifestations interact. Negative manifestations weaken it. It is therefore crucial to leverage the amplifying effect of as many positive micro-narratives as possible.

A second insight is that there is no “self-sustaining” effect here, and one should be skeptical of oversimplified, grand narratives about AI. For example, the United States’ technological leadership is extremely fragile in the face of an autocratic government. A European AI narrative should be mindful of this fragility when leveraging the amplifying effect of a cohesive, multi-level strategy.

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

These insights lead to the following recommendations for designing a connective, multi-level AI strategy:

  • People and their shared values should be at the heart of “bridge-building” between the levels
  • narratives that deal honestly with threats are more credible than utopias or dystopias, and
  • within the framework of constructive visions of the future, stories drawn from people’s everyday lives strengthen society’s sense of self-efficacy.

In this respect, addressing AI challenges is a shared task of shaping the future, in which narratives highlight the potential benefits for people.

 

Implications for research and teaching

A multitude of exciting questions arise for research and teaching. Important insights come from linking causal AI with management theory of complex, evolutionary systems.31 Accordingly, educational institutions such as universities and business schools are also realigning their strategies in the AI era.32

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

The focus is on the following areas of action:

  1. AI development and application competencies
  2. A connective strategic management (Strategy 5.0) at all levels
  3. A change of areas of responsibility and business processes through AI, as well as
  4. The integration of human resources management with AI management.

There is currently a high demand for dual education and training programs that combine new theoretical insights with practical experience. One topic is Vibe Coding, in which software developers no longer write the code line by line themselves but instead instruct an AI on what to create.

The Mannheim-based startup Osapiens, which is working on agent platforms that, for example, support the flow of sustainability data into key decisions, provides insights into relevant qualifications. In the past, the focus was on who could write the best code, says co-founder Stefan Wawrzinek. Today, it is important to understand the big picture in order to shape strategies in a comprehensive sense.33

 

Conclusion

  • To gain a competitive edge in the field of artificial intelligence, Europe needs a multi-level strategy
  • Innovation narratives in the form of micro-stories provide an important foundation for this
  • New waves of technology are currently emerging—such as Physical AI—where Europe can leverage its strengths
  • Our approach to multi-level strategies distinguishes between geopolitics and the environment (macro level), nations and regions (meso level), companies and public administration (micro level), and the level of society and the individual
  • We refer to the connection between these levels as vertical connectivity. This third dimension—alongside temporal and horizontal connectivity—expands the scope of connective strategic management (Strategy 5.0)
  • The diversity of micro-narratives illustrates the goal of multi-level strategies: to manage threats and generate positive impacts
  • The connecting effect of innovation narratives stems from the amplifying effect of many positive, small-scale stories. Given the fragility of grand AI narratives, skepticism is warranted
  • For the design of a multi-level AI strategy, it follows that credible everyday stories that clearly demonstrate the benefits for people have a connecting effect
  • Examples include successful, personal developments in a work environment increasingly shaped by AI.

 

References

[1] Klüwer, T., The Future Made in Germany—Why We Must Promote Innovation Now to Save Our Prosperity, Rowohlt 2025

[2] Lyotard, J.F., The Postmodern Condition: A Report on Knowledge, University of Minnesota Press 1984

[3] Oppert, S., Geoffrey Hinton – The Untold Story of AI’s Hidden Risks and the Man Who Warned the World, Independently 2025

[4] Bomke, L., Europe’s Second Chance—A Billion-Dollar Bet on New AI Labs. In: Handelsblatt, June 22, 2026, pp. 26-27

[5] Benninghoff, M., China’s New Stock Market Frenzy. In: Handelsblatt, August 20, 2026, pp. 34-35

[6] Hoffer, J., AI in End Devices Is Coming ‘Faster Than Expected. In: Handelsblatt, August 25, 2026, p. 20

[7] Alvarez de Souza Soares, P., et al., The Rebellion of AI Customers. In: Handelsblatt, July 10, 11, and 12, 2026, pp. 34-40

[8] Bomke, L., Holtermann, F., Scheuer, S., The New Gatekeepers of the AI Economy. In: Handelsblatt, August 21, 22, and 23, 2026, pp. 26-27

[9] Scheuer, S., This Chinese Model Is Causing a Stir Worldwide. In: Handelsblatt, July 20, 2026, p. 24

[10] Whittington, R., Strategy as Practice. In: Long Range Planning, 1996, Issue 5, pp. 731-735

[11] Geels, F., Technological Transitions as Evolutionary Reconfiguration Processes – A Multi-level Perspective and a Case Study. In: Research Policy, 2002, Issues 8-9, pp. 1257-1274

[12] Rüegg-Sturm, J., Grand, S., The St. Gallen Management Model, 3rd ed., Haupt 2017

[13] Foss, N.J., Felin, T., Strategic Organization – A Field in Search of Micro Foundations. In: Strategic Organization, November 2005, Issue 3, pp. 441-455

[14] Servatius, H.G., Development and Change in Strategic Management. In: Competivation Blog, September 19, 2025

[15] Servatius, H.G., Designing and Empowering Innovation Systems. In: Competivation Blog, February 22, 2018

[16] Servatius, H.G., Process-Oriented AI for Productivity Gains. In: Competivation Blog, March 12, 2025

[17] Delhaes, D., Researchers and Industry Call for More Freedom for Innovation. In: Handelsblatt, August 31, 2026, p. 14

[18] Brands, H. (ed.), Geopolitics of AI – Power, Conflicts, and the Future of Global Order, Johns Hopkins University Press, 2026

[19] Gusbeth, S., Heide, D., The Battle for AI Supremacy. In: Handelsblatt, August 4, 2026, pp. 6-7

[20] Heide, D., Alvarez de Souza Soares, P., The Governors’ AI Rebellion. In: Handelsblatt, July 15, 2026, pp. 10-11

[21] Kölling, M., Knees, L., Why Japan Doesn’t Depend on Anthropic. In: Handelsblatt, July 3, 4, and 5, 2026, pp. 30-31

[22] Simon, H., Hidden Champions – The New Rules of the Game in the Chinese Century, Campus 2021

[23] Davenport, T.H., Mittal, N., All In on AI – How Smart Companies Win Big with Artificial Intelligence, Harvard Business Press 2023

[24] Buchenau, M., Trump on the Path to Becoming a Machine-Human. In: Handelsblatt, August 28, 29, and 30, 2026, pp. 42-43

[25] Lutz, J., Two Digital States That Companies Dream Of. In: Handelsblatt, May 15, 16, and 17, 2026, pp. 60-62

[26] Fokul, J., The Architect of Digital Germany. In: Handelsblatt, May 15, 16, and 17, 2026, pp. 64-65

[27] Fokuhl, J., Just a Chatbot in Front of the Old Bureaucratic Apparatus? In: Handelsblatt, August 17, 2026, pp. 12-13

[28] Baecker, D., Digitalization, Suhrkamp 2026

[29] Hougaard, R., Carter, J., More Human – How the Power of AI Can Transform the Way You Lead, Harvard Business Review Press 2025

[30] Peer, M., Banks Promise AI Transformation Without Mass Layoffs. In: Handelsblatt, September 1, 2026, p. 36

[31] Servatius, H.G., Connecting Causal AI with Complex Evolutionary Systems. In: Compativation Blog, August 13, 2026

[32] Fleig, S., Artificial Intelligence Challenges Career Prospects. In: Handelsblatt, September 4, 2026, pp. 36-37

[33] Schimroszik, N., We Roll Out New AI Agents Every Month (Interview with Stefan Wawrzinek). In: Handelsblatt, September 7, 2026, pp. 26-27

Connective strategic management in the age of AI

Connective strategic management in the age of AI

The fifth stage of connective strategic management (Strategy 5.0) continues to evolve. Currently, the focus is on the connectivity between human and artificial intelligence. To better understand this connective intelligence, it helps to examine the forms of connectivity in strategic management more closely. This yields important implications for teaching and research regarding the changing workplace in the AI era.

In this new blog post, I summarize various forms of connectivity in the fifth stage of strategic management and draw conclusions regarding connective intelligence.

 

Digital Industrial Engineering as an Opportunity

A central theme of this year’s Hannover Messe was artificial intelligence (AI). Both established companies and startups presented innovative solutions. For example, the Limburg-based software manufacturer German Edge Cloud (GEC) presented the AI agent Digital Industrial Engineer, which serves as a sparring partner for engineers and thus makes the interaction between humans and machines more efficient. Many human capabilities are based on experience. This tacit knowledge must be combined with AI. GEC sees this as an important opportunity for differentiation. The agent utilizes this undocumented knowledge for learning processes. It is the task of managers to show appreciation for the human knowledge carriers.1

An important concept in mechanical engineering is Physical AI. This refers to the integration of hardware and artificial intelligence. One aspect of this is the ability of machines not only to process data but also to perceive their environment. At the Hannover Messe, Siemens presented its AI agent “Eigen,” which is designed to make engineers’ work 50 percent more efficient. This is achieved through a combination of automated processes and human oversight. In doing so, Siemens draws on its comprehensive and deep domain knowledge, which providers of basic AI models generally do not possess.2

 

Connective Intelligence Instead of Robomobbing

Artificial intelligence (AI) can trigger a modern “Luddite movement” among employees who fear losing their jobs. The term “robomobbing” is currently gaining traction to describe acts of sabotage against robots. Analyses by the industry association Bitkom show that 23 percent of respondents perceive AI as a threat. Resistance to AI is understandable if companies fail to communicate and act credibly.3

A crucial factor here is equipping employees to work with AI. So far, only a rough outline of how human and artificial intelligence will interact in the future is visible. In this context of connective intelligence, not only is AI evolving at a rapid pace, but the human skills in demand are also changing. This raises the question of what lessons can be drawn for the future of work from various forms of connectivity.

 

Lessons from Forms of Connectivity in Strategic Management

In response to new challenges facing companies, strategic management has gone through various stages over the past decades, which continue to evolve dynamically.4 These stages focus on the following areas:

  • Market and financial orientation (Strategy 1.0)
  • technology and innovation orientation (Strategy 2.0)
  • sustainability orientation (Strategy 3.0) and
  • resilience orientation, including necessary restructuring (Strategy 4.0).

In the current fifth stage of connective strategic management, the difficulty lies in the complexity of the challenges. Many companies must navigate strategic and organizational realignments while becoming more resilient, digital, and sustainable.5 The lesson for an emerging connective intelligence is that this requires an integrated perspective. Companies that possess such a perspective have significant advantages over others.

An effective corporate innovation system consists of various interconnected areas of activity. These areas—such as research, innovation marketing, and a culture that fosters innovation—require specific competencies. Successful innovation managers possess the ability to design connections.6 The lesson for connective intelligence is that this ability can be learned, yet it is neglected in our education system, which is oriented toward distinct disciplines. This leads to the recommendation that management theory and research be oriented more toward a transdisciplinary and design-oriented approach.7

In strategic management, there has been a paradigm shift from mechanistic to one that manages complexity.8 Digital champions recognized the potential of the theory of complex, evolutionary systems early on and applied it in management.9 Startups have thus become the most valuable companies in the world. The implication for connective intelligence is to learn from the positive experiences of these companies and to adapt the newer complexity theory to the AI era. This, too, requires design-oriented management research in real-world laboratories of change.

Perhaps the greatest challenge is improving cooperation among stakeholders from politics, academia, business, and society—for example, in the context of digital change. In recent decades, global competition among innovation ecosystems has intensified. These have become key value drivers for companies and regions.10 Germany has rested on the laurels of past successes for too long and must now catch up. The lesson for connective intelligence is that the relevant sectors must improve their ability to act jointly and in a dialogue-oriented manner in order to achieve competitive advantages.11 The following figure summarizes these forms of connectivity and lessons for connective intelligence.

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

For some time now, research has been exploring what approaches to connective intelligence might look like. The term, coined by Derrick de Kerckhove, initially focused on interaction with the Internet.12

In projects on connective strategic management, we have found that people with contextual and relationship-oriented intelligence are key. These skills can be developed.13 They also play an important role when working with AI. Both upskilling and deskilling are possible in this context.

 

Upskilling and Deskilling Through AI

In a work environment accelerated by AI, there is an expansion of employees’ skills (upskilling) but also a reduction (deskilling). Therefore, it is crucial to promote upskilling and limit deskilling.

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

The aspects of upskilling mentioned in many case studies are:

  • Time savings from routine tasks taken over by AI
  • Using AI as a tool to improve one’s own skills
  • stimulation of human creativity through content specifically generated by AI, as well as
  • a stronger focus on relational intelligence and empathy, which are used in a complementary manner to AI.

Potential deskilling is not addressed as extensively. Causes for this may include:

  • A superficial understanding of a topic driven by convenience (offloading)
  • Loss of skills in tasks taken over by AI, e.g., reading, understanding, critical evaluation, and writing
  • a decline in self-generated new knowledge coupled with a loss of problem-solving skills, as well as
  • neglected oversight of the results produced by AI.

Research on connective intelligence—which seeks to answer the question of what the best connections between human and artificial intelligence are depending on the situation—is still in a relatively early phase.

 

Approaches to Connective Intelligence

Ethan Mollick, an innovation researcher teaching at the Wharton School in Philadelphia, offers several recommendations for connecting human and artificial intelligence.

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie
  1. Try to incorporate AI. In doing so, it is important to recognize what AI is good at and what it is not. This ability grows with experience
  2. Stay in the control loop as a human. Human expertise and judgment are essential for correcting the incorrect results generated by AI
  3. Treat the AI as a clearly defined persona representing a specific type. In this context, the AI is like a fast-working intern who wants to please and tends to twist the truth
  4. Assume that AI is evolving dynamically. Newer AI technologies, such as agent systems, have specific strengths but also pose threats
  5. View AI as a connection engine. In this way, AI is capable of developing new ideas from the combination of existing knowledge
  6. Education and training should view working with AI as a new professional competency. In this context, good prompting is just one of the skills within the framework of evolving connective intelligence.14

These approaches to enhanced intelligence give rise to specific performance patterns in the AI era.

 

Performance Patterns in the AI Era

In recent decades, a wealth of leadership theories has emerged, the practical relevance of which is highly dependent on time and context. Of particular importance for human-resource management within the framework of connective strategic management is the concept of connective leadership. Its recommendation for highly competitive and power-oriented managers is to expand their own leadership styles and behavioral preferences.15 However, the topic of artificial intelligence does not feature in this concept.

The development of AI technologies has proceeded in waves. There have been repeated phases of disillusionment, such as currently with generative AI using large language models.16 In most cases, the answer to the question of which next wave of AI (NextAI) will be successful is marked by great uncertainty.

In the AI era, it is therefore crucial to link the dynamically evolving performance in artificial intelligence with the ability to design connections. A conceptual foundation for this is the design of trustworthy high-performance systems.17 Depending on the characteristics of the two dimensions mentioned, the following performance patterns emerge:

  • Losers in the AI era
  • holistic non-technicians
  • AI specialists and
  • winners with connective intelligence.

It can be assumed that both holistic non-technicians and AI specialists should further develop their mindset.

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

The disadvantage of holistic non-technicians is that, while they possess strong skills in integrative design, they are unable to leverage the new opportunities offered by AI or work with AI technologies that are not very powerful. AI specialists lack the integrated perspective required to understand the complex interrelationships of an AI application and its potential consequences. Therefore, in the AI era, leaders must train their connective intelligence. In our research and teaching accompanying projects, we examine the success factors of these winning types. The looming disruption of management education is serious.18

 

The Significance of Strategy 5.0 for Management Education

I asked AI what the significance of Strategy 5.0 is for management education. The answer summarizes some of my recent publications and highlights the following points:

  1. Expansion of the competency profile of executives and employees
  2. Integration of new technologies with AI as a partner
  3. Change of teaching methods and research approaches, as well as
  4. Focus on the intersection of digitalization, sustainability, and resilience.

I find this result surprisingly good because it not only identifies important aspects but also demonstrates a certain creativity.

You can continue the question-and-answer game for as long as you like, receiving a wealth of in-depth information and examples from the AI. Of course, you can also “activate” your own intelligence and explore the implications for existing management education.

In my view, many bachelor’s and master’s programs in business administration (BA) have the following weaknesses:

  1. Business administration is understood as an unconnected collection of functional business disciplines (e.g., marketing) and interdisciplinary fields (e.g., innovation)
  2. Entrepreneurship and venture capital are not required courses
  3. The curriculum neglects the fundamentals and applications of artificial intelligence in practical exercises
  4. Strategy courses—if offered at all—are typically introduced relatively late and address the initial stage of market- and finance-oriented strategic management (Strategy 1.0) in a more or less uncritical manner
  5. Universities do not, at least not in depth, teach the fundamentals of the theory of complex, evolutionary systems and their relevance, e.g., for agile project management
  6. When research approaches are taught, empiricism dominates, while design-oriented research is “uncharted territory” for many business administration professors.

One possible way to reorient the “Introduction to Business Administration” course would be to place connective strategic management at the beginning of a degree program and, using practical examples, provide an overall picture of the challenges. Since all students now work with AI in one form or another, they can contribute their own important experiences to practical exercises on the topic of connective intelligence. We have been pursuing this approach for several years in bachelor’s and master’s programs, in executive education, and in the supervision of theses.

Given the speed at which the world of work is changing due to AI, it is not surprising that the topics of Strategy 5.0 and connective intelligence are also evolving rapidly. This opens up new opportunities for the German education system. However, education providers who cling to outdated models run the risk of being left behind. The same fate threatens organizations that neglect continuing education.

 

Challenges in Continuing Education and Leadership Development

Figures from the McKinsey HR Monitor show that German companies have cut their budgets for employee continuing education by 30 percent over the past two years. This places Germany at the bottom of the list in a European comparison. In the AI era, attempts to cut costs in the short term undermine competitiveness in the medium term, as employees need to acquire new skills. Furthermore, many companies face the challenge of choosing the right approach given a complex continuing education system. As a result, learning processes—for example, on AI topics—often take place not in traditional seminars but informally within the context of projects. This underscores the importance of customized training tailored to the specific situation, which, for instance, sharpens critical judgment in the application of AI while using AI as a tool.19

The growing importance of artificial intelligence is also changing the demands placed on executives. Above all, companies are looking for individuals who have experience with concrete AI projects and can demonstrate that they have successfully navigated the changes associated with these new technologies. Since the AI-based realignment of a company is a complex yet highly specific task that is also constantly evolving, it is essential to continually adapt and develop the skills acquired to the specific situation at hand. This requires a growth mindset with a passion for lifelong learning. Such a mindset supports both the use of AI as a tool for strategic management20 and the improvement of process-oriented AI to increase productivity.21

In leading companies, new AI-based roles and job profiles have emerged that open up excellent career opportunities. These include the AI Realignment Officer, the AI Solutions Architect, and the Forward Deployment Engineer. An AI Realignment Officer designs the AI-based strategic, operational, organizational, and cultural realignment of organizations. Job postings still use the outdated term “Transformation Officer,” even though the focus is not on a one-time transformation but on numerous, rapid adaptations to or anticipations of new developments. The AI Solution Architect also plays a key role. As an AI architect, their task is to determine which AI applications and processes take priority based on an AI strategy, what the required IT architecture looks like, and how to successfully integrate the relevant data. This requires many Forward Deployment Engineers who understand the complex problems of internal and external customers and develop tailor-made solutions “from the ground up” through iterative processes. A shared core competency of these “bridge-building roles” is the ability to design solutions that connect.

 

Conclusion

  • AI agents learn from the experiential knowledge of engineers. This presents an opportunity for European industry if it succeeds in connecting human and artificial intelligence
  • Lessons in this regard emerge from the various forms of connectivity within the framework of the fifth stage of development of a connecting strategic management
  • Research that combines human and artificial intelligence is still in its infancy
  • This has important implications for gaining a competitive edge in the AI era, where the key lies in combining the capabilities of artificial intelligence with the ability to foster cooperation
  • This requires new approaches to executive education and development.

 

References

[1] Wittenbrink, J., “Sparring Partner for the Factory.” In: Handelsblatt, April 20, 2026, pp. 26–27

[2] Höpner, A., Siemens Introduces First AI Agent for Engineers. In: Handelsblatt, April 21, 2026, pp. 26–27

[3] Merten, M., Bomke, L., Man vs. Machine – How Bosses Help Their Employees Overcome Their Fear of AI. In: Handelsblatt, April 10, 11, and 12, 2026, pp. 54–55

[4] Servatius, H.G., Development and Transformation of Strategic Management. In: Competivation Blog, September 19, 2025

[5] Servatius, H.G., Triple Strategic Realignment. In: Competivation Blog, June 7, 2024

[6] Servatius, H.G., Designing and Empowering Innovation Systems. In: Competivation Blog, February 22, 2018

[7] Servatius, H.G., Creative Innovation Research on AI Applications. In: Competivation Blog, March 25, 2026

[8] Servatius, H.G., Learning from Successful Digital Companies. In: Competivation Blog, July 12, 2024

[9] Servatius, H.G., Learning to Design Solutions for Complex Management Problems. In: Competivation Blog, July 15, 2025

[10] Servatius, H.G., Designing Innovative Stakeholder Ecosystems. In: Competivation Blog, January 10, 2023

[11] Servatius, H.G., Management Education 5.0: Toward Dialogue-Based Action. In: Competivation Blog, January 13, 2024

[12] de Kerckhove, D., Connected Intelligence – The Arrival of the Web Society,
GB Gardners Books 1998

[13] Servatius, H.G., Strategic Leadership with Contextual and Relationship-Oriented Intelligence. In: Competivation Blog, March 14, 2023

[14] Mollick, E., Co-Intelligence – Living and Working with AI, Portfolio 2024

[15] Servatius, H.G., Human Resource Management in the Age of Connective Management. In: Competivation Blog, January 19, 2021

[16] Servatius, H.G., Development of AI Technologies. In: Competivation Blog, February 19, 2025

[17] Servatius, H.G., Designing Trustworthy High-Performance Systems. In: Competivation Blog, January 29, 2026

[18] Servatius, H.G., Disruption of Management Education for AI-Based Realignments. In: Competivation Blog, October 10, 2025

[19] Merten, M., Budgets for Continuing Education Cut by 30 Percent. In: Handelsblatt, May 13, 2026, p. 30

[20] Servatius, H.G., AI as a Tool for Strategic Management. In: Competivation Blog, May 1, 2025

[21] Servatius, H.G., Process-Oriented AI for Increased Productivity. In: Competivation Blog, March 12, 2025

[22] Obmann, C., Schimroszik, N., These new roles come with six-figure salaries. In: Handelsblatt, May 19, 2026, pp. 32–33

Design-oriented innovation research on AI applications

Design-oriented innovation research on AI applications

Around the world, many companies face the challenge of keeping pace with artificial intelligence (AI) and gaining a competitive edge through AI tools that leverage their specific expertise. This development is leading to a renaissance in design-oriented management and innovation research, which aims to bridge the gap between theory and practice. In the process, research is shifting from empirical work at universities to connective design in real-world laboratories of change.

 

In this blog post, I outline the development of the design-oriented research approach, highlight its advantages, and explain a general procedural concept.

 

A decisive year for AI adoption

2026 could be the year that determines for many companies whether they achieve a breakthrough in AI adoption or remain stuck with isolated pilot projects. According to an analysis by the market research firm Forrester, only 15 percent of decision-makers report that the use of AI has so far made a measurable contribution to their companies’ operating results. This could lead them to postpone about a quarter of their planned AI spending until 2027. However, the danger of being too hesitant in adopting AI is that it creates a gap that is difficult to close.1

On the other hand, pioneering companies are succeeding in achieving significant competitive advantages with AI tailored to their specific situations. These pioneers practice design-oriented management and innovation research to lay the groundwork for success. One example is Siemens, which aims to develop the world’s largest and broadest range of industrial AI applications and double its enterprise value.2

The German Economic Research Institute (IW) forecasts that the potential for increasing gross value added through the use of AI in Germany by 2034 stands at 440 billion euros. Of this, 110 billion euros is attributable to potential innovations and 330 billion euros to increased productivity. For Germany as an industrial hub, the application of AI in particular presents an opportunity. Google, a subsidiary of the U.S. technology conglomerate Alphabet, has also recognized this. It plans to invest 5.5 billion euros in Germany and open a center for AI applications in Berlin, where its own researchers will also be based.3

This new situation has exciting implications for the design of AI ecosystems.

 

Designing AI ecosystems

The opportunity for established companies lies in knowledge-specific AI, where AI tools leverage and amplify the companies’ specialized expertise.4 This is most effectively achieved within AI ecosystems.

The term “AI ecosystem” refers to a dynamic network with strong connections between various actors who use AI technologies to create and disseminate innovations. AI ecosystems can be concentrated in a single region and have developed around a central hub, such as a university or a company. The world’s best-known and most influential AI ecosystem emerged in Silicon Valley in the San Francisco Bay Area. Stanford University near Palo Alto formed the core of Silicon Valley in the 1930s. In 1939, Bill Hewlett and David Packard founded the company HP there in a garage. Later, leading semiconductor companies – which gave the valley its name – and some of the major AI providers established themselves here.

Stanford University served as a model for Helmut Schöneberger, the head of the Munich-based startup incubator UnternehmerTUM. Crucial to its success were the collaboration with the Technical University of Munich and the support of BMW shareholder Susanne Klatten. In addition, other startup incubators have emerged in Munich, such as the Center for Digital Technology and Management (CDTM), which offers the transdisciplinary master’s program in Technology Management, works closely with industry partners, and has spawned over 250 startups.

By 2025, startups in Munich had received 3.3 billion euros in venture capital, thereby pushing Berlin into second place in this category, where startups raised 2.7 billion euros. However, AI ecosystems with successful startups have also emerged in other German regions.

Key players in AI ecosystems include:

  • Decision-makers in relevant policy areas and at various levels of state and regional government
  • Universities and schools
  • AI startups that originated as spin-offs or have established themselves in a region
  • Venture capitalists who use venture capital to finance the growth of AI startups
  • Major providers of AI hardware and software that shape financial markets with their financial clout and have a significant impact on the environment and society, as well as
  • established companies and their employees, who use AI, collaborate with startups, and invest in them.

Pharmaceutical research provides an interesting example of new opportunities for collaboration between established companies and startups.

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

In the pharmaceutical industry, tech-bio companies, such as the French startup Owkin, are accelerating early-stage drug discovery with the help of AI. A first wave of drugs developed in this way is currently in clinical trials. One possible form of collaboration is for AI biotechs to take on early-stage drug discovery and for established pharmaceutical companies to handle the later phases and commercialization. Another option is for pharmaceutical companies to acquire AI startups and build up their own relevant capabilities. In any case, this research-intensive industry is facing a fundamental change, in which the design of AI ecosystems is a key success factor.5 This example illustrates that as industries evolve, management research changes as well.

However, artificial intelligence is not only a driver of productivity and innovation but also poses a potential threat. In light of geopolitical shifts, it is crucial for Europe to regain its ability to shape the future. A trustworthy AI can be an important means to this end. The recent dispute between the U.S. government and the U.S. startup Anthropic illustrates just how political the design of AI ecosystems has become.6 This, too, is leading to significant changes in management research.

An important aspect that is often overlooked in AI ecosystems is the environmental and social impact of AI technologies. For instance, large language models require the work of crawlers that collect data and annotators who comment on, evaluate, and label texts and images. This work often takes place out of the public eye, frequently in countries of the “Global South.” Transparency in these supply chains is low.7

 

Management research in real-world laboratories of change

Empirical approaches, predominantly originating from universities, have long dominated business research. The authors publish the results of their work in academic journals, which practitioners rarely read. Critics of this retreat into an “academic ivory tower” argue that the practical relevance of research has diminished. This criticism is not new, but it has grown stronger.8

Universities defend their position by arguing that the practical relevance of empirical research is based on “field trips” in which the perspectives of relevant actors are analyzed. However, the goal of such work is generally not to design concrete objects – such as new AI-based business models –within their specific context.9

In this respect, business research differs from the design-oriented approach of engineering sciences, which takes place predominantly in laboratories and pilot plants.

Due to the growing importance of inter- or transdisciplinary research, the proportion of connective design is also increasing in management science. This practice- and design-oriented research is increasingly taking place in real-world laboratories of change.10 A key driver of this development is artificial intelligence, which acts as a catalyst for the founding of startups and the realignment of established companies. We believe that, following a phase of retreat into universities, management research should once again take place more strongly in practice and utilize design-oriented approaches.

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

This response to the questions of how and where research approaches should be conducted marks the beginning of a new chapter in the history of management research. A key feature of this reorientation toward connective design is research in which scientists, consultants, and practitioners bring their diverse perspectives and strengths together. The benefit lies in better solutions to complex problems based on new scientific insights.11

The development of humanoid robots provides an example. In this rapidly growing market, companies have the best chances when they combine software and hardware expertise. Data from the real world is the biggest bottleneck here. The Metzingen-based manufacturer Neura Robotics has therefore decided to build training facilities for robots. One of the first of these “gyms” is being developed in collaboration with the Technical University of Munich at the Munich Institute of Robotics and Machine Intelligence (MIRMI) at Munich Airport. In international competition with companies from the U.S. and China, rapid scaling is crucial for this AI application.12

Since design-oriented management research is less widespread, I would like to briefly outline its history. Personally, over the past few decades, I have repeatedly observed how different the thought and language patterns of the relevant actors are in theory and practice.

 

Principles and pioneers of creative management research

Design-oriented management research is based on similar principles and has been shaped by several pioneers.13 These principles are:

  1. Action research, pioneered by social psychologist Kurt Lewin. Lewin advocated for a connection between theory and practice to solve real-world problems.
  2. General design theory, as defined by Nobel Prize-winning economist Herbert Simon.14 Simon defines this as the science of designing human-made artifacts and systems.
  3. Action Science, conceived by Harvard professor Chris Argyris.15 Argyris’s primary goal is to make knowledge usable in order to improve actions within organizations.
  4. The Design Science Research (DSR) approach developed by Alan Hevner at the University of South Florida.16 This concept, which is particularly widespread in business informatics, focuses on solving complex, real-world problems through innovative IT systems.
  5. Action Design Research (ADR), described by various scholars, which combines Action Research and Design Science Research.
Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

Pioneers of design-oriented management research include Joan Ernst van Aken and Georges Romme, who teach at Eindhoven University, as well as David Denyer from Cranfield University in the UK. Van Aken aims to bridge the gap between management theory and practice. The focus is on transdisciplinary research to solve practical management problems. Building on design theory, Romme tests iterative processes in organizational design.17  Denyer views management knowledge as a malleable resource for solving real-world problems. His solution-oriented approach seeks to ensure practical application through mechanisms of action and evidence-based verification using various information sources.

The advantages of a design-oriented approach are particularly evident in innovation and sustainability research.

 

Advantages in innovation and sustainability research

When applying AI, the advantages of a design-oriented approach to innovation and sustainability research unfold most notably in companies that practice this approach in self-similar Strategy 5.0 labs. The goal of such a real-world lab is to connect the various fields of action for AI applications.18 It is helpful if the countercurrent principle – combining a top-down AI strategy with a bottom-up, harmoniously diverse range of AI applications – is effectively implemented.

Based on our experience from a series of projects, the following benefits are of particular importance:

  • The removal of barriers to innovation
  • high-performing and trustworthy innovation ecosystems
  • motivated high-performance teams
  • connective design as a core competency
  • improved technology transfer
  • accelerated learning loops using agile methods, as well as
  • concrete results and measurable success for all stakeholders.

These advantages enable a realignment of innovation systems.

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

The shortcomings in Germany’s energy and mobility transition are an example of how important it is to remove barriers to innovation.19 The aim here is to translate new insights from innovation research into practical action.

The goal is to design high-performing and trustworthy innovation ecosystems.20 A hallmark of these systems is improved collaboration among stakeholders from the political, scientific, economic, and social sectors.

Motivated high-performance teams play a key role in shaping innovation research.21 Leaders have the task of exemplifying and fostering an entrepreneurial mindset. This begins with education and continues throughout one’s professional career.

A core competency to be developed in this context is connective design.22 This requires a reorientation of teaching and research using AI as a tool. Such human-centric AI permeates all disciplines.

A positive side effect is improved technology transfer.23 The goal here is to overcome the German paradox between strengths in basic research and weaknesses in commercialization.

One way to achieve this is through accelerated learning loops within organizations.24 Agile methods are used for this purpose. It is important to adapt a general approach to specific types of problems and the situation at hand.

In doing so, all stakeholders should focus on concrete results and measurable successes.25 In joint programs, this is achieved through transparent performance management.

In the following, I would like to explain a suitable approach.

 

Steps of a general procedural concept

An example of design-oriented innovation and sustainability research is the AI-based strategic and organizational realignment of a company.26 For topics such as this, a general procedural concept consisting of the six steps shown in the figure has proven effective.

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

The first step is an analysis of the state of research, best-practice examples, and the specific initial situation. The task here is to combine an internal and an external perspective in an audit.

It is then crucial to develop a comprehensive understanding of the problem’s complexity, to identify its causes, and to coordinate efforts among the relevant stakeholders. Collaboration between various disciplines and practitioners is more successful than disciplinary research approaches.

Transdisciplinary teams also play a key role in the subsequent design and selection of creative solutions. What may be uncharted territory for a single organization can, when taken as a whole, contribute significantly to scientific progress.

A defining characteristic of design-oriented innovation research is the implementation of pilot projects for Minimum Viable Solutions (MVS). These pilots are tested in real-world laboratories of change. For established companies, working in learning loops often requires a shift in mindset. Human resources development can support this effort.

The fifth step is planning and executing the implementation. This is closely linked to financing the scaling process. German startups have long complained of disadvantages, for example, compared to the U.S. Therefore, an improvement in the political framework conditions should be sought, particularly in this step.

In parallel, transparent performance measurement takes place, for example, using the Objectives and Key Results (OKR) method. In this context, “transparent” means that performance management does not occur in sectoral silos. For a policy that sets goals but neglects to measure success, this involves a learning process aimed at joint system design by innovation managers.

 

Innovation managers design complex, evolutionary systems

As early as in our 2014 book publication “The Innovation Manager,” we concluded that a central task of innovation managers lies in the design of innovation systems and the connection of various fields of action.27 Subsequently, we engaged intensively with the behavioral economic perspective of such connective design.28

The scientific foundation for connective design is the theory of complex, evolutionary systems. The application of this approach to socio-technical systems has triggered a paradigm shift in strategic management.29 U.S. digital companies have mastered this new management paradigm better than the European economy.30

Another insight is that innovation research is a transdisciplinary design task.

 

Interdisciplinary or transdisciplinary?

We deliberately use the term transdisciplinary to make it clear that, unlike the term interdisciplinary, it is not merely about mediating between scientific disciplines, but also about involving non-scientific actors and establishing a connection between theory and practical design.31 The particular complexity of transdisciplinary innovation research stems from

  • the heterogeneity of the disciplines, which ranges from natural science and technical research through various policy fields to management science and organizational psychology
  • the diverse interests and thought patterns, e.g., of scientists and practitioners
  • the dynamics of development and the number of levels, from geopolitics down to the individual, as well as
  • the different roles of the actors, e.g., as neutral observers or personally affected individuals.

Unfortunately, transdisciplinary innovation research has so far lacked recognition in universities. The reasons for this are manifold. One important reason is likely that the traditional academic and publication system tends to reward disciplinary excellence. This presents an opportunity for applied research.

 

Transdisciplinary research on sustainability innovations

Our book, published in 1994, on the “ecological reorientation” of automotive companies emerged from consulting projects and accompanying research at the University of Stuttgart.32 This research was transdisciplinary, but had only a limited impact because German companies and policymakers at the time did not implement our recommendations – for example, regarding new propulsion systems.

Thirty years later, this industry – so vital to the German economy – is grappling with serious problems. VW, the world’s second-largest automaker by vehicle sales, is undergoing a process of strategic and organizational realignment.33 At the same time, the geopolitical landscape is marked by extreme uncertainty.

This example illustrates that, when it comes to sustainability innovation, transdisciplinary and design-oriented research is of crucial importance for securing our country’s prosperity. 34 In recent years, the field has evolved dynamically. The intersection of environmental technology and artificial intelligence has moved to the center of attention. New market leaders can emerge from collaborations between established companies and digital greentech startups if European policymakers succeed in improving the framework conditions.35

One example is the German-Luxembourgish startup R3 Robotics, which has developed an AI-powered robotics platform for battery recycling. In this way, Europe can reduce its dependence on imports and increase the sustainability of batteries.36

In my personal experience, students remain very interested in such topics because they recognize the resulting career opportunities. This provides important impetus for our expert network.

 

Combining management consulting and human resources development with design-oriented innovation and sustainability research

Our expert network Competivation has long combined management consulting and human resources development. The advantage for clients is a better value for money than with traditional consultants, as the focus is on the qualifications of the employees who are actively involved in the projects.

For several years now, we have been supplementing this service with design-oriented innovation and sustainability research. In doing so, we supervise the theses of dual-track students and external doctoral candidates who are working on relevant projects within the client organization. The advantage here is that the research is tailored to the specific situation of the company. The researchers and their companies benefit from the extensive experience of our experts.

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

With this approach, Competivation has created a unique international selling point geared toward the needs of the AI era.

Design-oriented research also has far-reaching implications for university teaching. We see ourselves as an innovative educational provider that teaches the ability to a of AI-supported connective design of solutions for complex management problems.37

 

Conclusion

  • When applying AI, many companies face the challenge of defending their position and gaining competitive advantages through a specific approach
  • In this context, the design of AI ecosystems is crucial
  • Parallel to this development, research approaches and locations are shifting toward design-oriented innovation research in real-world laboratories of change
  • In this context, design-oriented management and innovation research is experiencing a renaissance stemming from a number of advantages
  • In this transdisciplinary research approach, a six-step procedure has proven effective, which is adapted to the respective problem type and situation.
Innovation narratives for a connective multi-level AI strategy

Designing trustworthy high-performance systems

In recent years, the importance of connective strategic management has continued to grow. In light of the dynamic development of artificial intelligence (AI) and new geopolitical challenges, the design of trustworthy high-performance systems has become a focal point of interest. In this context, the term „high performance“ is being reinterpreted in business and politics. An important field of action here is design-oriented management research.

 

In our first blog post of 2026, I address the question of what important areas of action for Europe in terms of trustworthy high-performance systems are.

 

High performance in business and politics reinterpreted

For Jeanette zu Fürstenberg, who is responsible for Europe at the US fund General Catalyst, there is an opportunity for the old continent in connecting startups with the world of established industrial companies. Her successful investments include Mistral in France and the defense company Helsing in Germany. These companies focus on artificial intelligence (AI) that uses highly specialized application knowledge. Her publication „Wie gut wir sind, zeigt sich in Krisenzeiten“ (How good we are is revealed in times of crisis) was named Management Book of the Year in 2025. For her, the basis for a European high-performance system that can achieve reindustrialization is resilience, which enables recovery as quickly as possible after external shocks.1 In 2025, the number of startups founded in Germany reached a record high.

The topic of high-performance organizations is not new. High-performance organizations are characterized by high-performance teams. As early as the 1950s, the British Tavistock Institute developed an initial foundation with its socio-technical systems approach. I described the results of consulting projects on the characteristics of high-performance organizations in an article in Harvard Manager magazine in 1988. One important finding is that visionary leadership creates the framework for teams that work in a more self-organized manner.2

McKinsey consultants Jon Katzenbach and Douglas Smith examined the question of what characterizes high-performance teams.3 However, further developments have shown that, despite considerable efforts, empirical research is struggling with the design of high-performance organizations.4 AI is now giving performance management new impetus to improve the connection between strategy implementation and motivation.5

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

US tech companies with artificial intelligence (AI) now dominate the global economy. By the end of 2025, 61 of the world’s 100 most valuable companies will be from the US. The dominance of the US results from the unique strength of seven tech giants, which together have a market value of €18.3 trillion. An important driver of this development is the hype surrounding artificial intelligence (AI). Germany is represented in the top 100 ranking with the companies SAP (rank 40), Siemens (72), the European joint venture Airbus (91), and Allianz (100). In view of geopolitical changes, this concentration of power raises the question of how great the danger of dependence on the US is. 6 In the AI chip market, competitive pressure is increasing for market leader Nvidia.

AI chips are becoming increasingly powerful, but at the same time, AI increases the risk of disinformation. With a global market share of 85.2%, AI chip manufacturer Nvidia has a dominant position ahead of Broadcom (10.3%), Marvell (2.1%), and AMD (1.8%). Challengers AMD and Meta have announced a new AI system for data centers (Helios platform) that is expected to deliver a significant performance boost. Nvidia is countering with its new Rubin chip generation.7

However, there is a risk of a loss of trust in AI due to the risk of disinformation from fake accounts. AI bots falsify content, imitate people, and post automatically on social media. Such deepfakes can cause great economic damage and, for example, ruin a brand’s reputation.8

Large language models and free AI tools often lead to a loss of quality and trust because they are not trained for high performance, but rather for the production of average knowledge. When AI users are under time pressure and there are no quality standards in place, „AI slop“ can result. Although this produces faster results, the quality declines. Possible consequences include a loss of reputation and trust. When using AI, it is therefore important to supplement content with expert knowledge after quality control.9

AI and geopolitical challenges are reinterpreting the concept of high performance. Not all AI is trustworthy. We understand a trustworthy high-performance system to be a system (e.g., a company, a region, or a state) that performs very well compared to the competition and is trusted by the recipients of its services. In addition, these service recipients are willing and able to pay for the services. High-performance systems must therefore justify their higher prices (e.g., through „German quality,“ technical superiority, or a luxury brand).

Reinterpreting high performance means that high-performance systems are characterized by both success and trustworthy behavior. If neither of these is the case, we speak of system failure. Most socio-technical systems fall somewhere in between. Cases where only one of the two criteria is met are interesting. An existing pattern of success is at risk when a previously successful system, such as that of the AI champions, loses trust. This could result in a transitional phase with new opportunities, for example, if Europe, which has been less successful in digitalization to date, scores points with trust.

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

Peter Frankopan, a British professor of global history teaching at Oxford, sees the world in a transitional phase similar to that of the 1920s, when the old order was not yet dead and a new one had not yet been born.10

The question is therefore how Europe can seize its opportunities and become a designer of trustworthy high-performance systems.

 

Strategic realignment in a phase of transition

In the first nine months of 2025, DAX companies spent €6 billion on restructuring. The highest restructuring costs in 2025 were incurred by Mercedes (€1.4 billion), Volkswagen (€900 million), Siemens and Commerzbank (€500 million each). The automotive, mechanical engineering, and chemical industries are particularly affected. At the end of September 2025, 120,300 fewer people were employed in German industry than a year earlier. Many companies are offering generous severance packages. Often, one round of restructuring is followed by another without solving the underlying problems. This would require a strategic realignment after restructuring.11

The term „strategic realignment“ describes an innovative approach to coordinating existing and new system elements (e.g., business model, strategy, technologies, customers, competencies, organization, culture, and environment). Realignments usually have a profound effect over a longer, undefined period of time in many parallel learning steps. Complex interactions play an important role in this process, resulting in specific patterns that are difficult to predict.

During a phase of transition, companies must manage complex realignment processes. In a successful, innovative company, important system elements are well coordinated. This alignment often takes place through fine-tuning, in which management continuously adapts the strategy to changes in the environment, for example. If this is not done, the company develops in the direction of misalignment. Management and supervisory boards often recognize this creeping decline too late. The result is an established company in a permanent crisis that requires restructuring.

The terms restructuring and transformation are now often used synonymously. Both terms describe a temporary, comprehensive change. Unfortunately, the inflationary use of the term transformation conveys the illusion that complex realignment processes are limited in time. The example of artificial intelligence clearly shows that such a static worldview is naive.

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

A longer-term goal of strategic realignments is the design of trustworthy high-performance systems.

 

Fields of action for trustworthy high-performance systems

In times of increasing polarization, high-performance systems are characterized by their ability to bring people together. History teaches us that the risk of polarization increases during periods of technological and political upheaval. This also applies to the changes brought about by artificial intelligence (AI). It is crucial that people see themselves as active participants in shaping change rather than passive objects of it. The complementarity of humans and AI is a malleable system. The performance of such a system depends on the ability to improve connections between the actors and the system elements. In our application-oriented research and teaching, we start with the thesis that the following fields of action, shown in the figure, are important in the design of trustworthy high-performance systems:

  • A connective strategic management for a triple realignment
  • high-performance teams with a growth mindset in a phase of transition
  • the connection of trustworthy partners from politics, business, science, and society, and
  • design-oriented management research in real-world laboratories of change.

Interdisciplinary university teaching faces the task of imparting the relevant skills for these fields, e.g., in the area of entrepreneurship for AI applications.

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

In the following, I will discuss these fields of action and skills in more detail.

 

Connective strategic management for a triple realignment

Since the 1960s, new challenges have led to various stages of development in strategic management.13 We distinguish between

  • a market- and finance-oriented stage (Strategy 1.0)
  • a technology- and innovation-oriented stage (Strategy 2.0)
  • a sustainability-oriented stage (Strategy 3.0) and
  • a resilience-oriented stage (Strategy 4.0).

In the current fifth stage of development (Strategy 5.0), the challenge lies in connecting the previous stages. Companies must become more resilient, more digital, and more sustainable at the same time.14 This requires the connective design of threefold strategic and organizational realignments. Such a triple realignment takes place in the context of serious changes in the political environment. The current situation is historically unprecedented. Therefore, the contextual intelligence of management plays an important role.15

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

German policymakers should create the framework for a cohesive strategic management approach through fundamental reforms. When the first signs of macroeconomic weakness appeared in 2018, they were harbingers of the most severe and longest industrial recession the Federal Republic has ever experienced. German industry has since lost much of its competitiveness. Experts are calling for new approaches to supply-oriented innovation policy and communication that conveys the need for a change of course. Politicians must implement the promised fundamental reforms. Such a new beginning can only succeed with solidarity instead of polarization.16

In this environment, resilience-oriented strategic management is becoming increasingly important.17  At this year’s World Economic Forum in Davos, the differing positions of the US president and European representatives clashed.18  Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney suggests that in a world where major powers are becoming imperialists who blackmail other states, middle powers and smaller countries should form trustworthy partnerships.19

Such cooperation plays a decisive role not only at the geopolitical level, but also in high-performance teams.

 

High-performance teams with a growth mindset in a phase of transition

Black Forest Lab (BFL), currently Germany’s most valuable AI startup, is based in Freiburg, was founded in 2024, and develops AI models for image generation based on text. The founders are part of the core team behind the open-source AI model Stable Diffusion, the text-to-image model that generates digital images from text and, alongside ChatGPT, sparked the global AI hype in 2022. BFL’s Flux models are now one of Google’s biggest competitors. Important impetus for the work of the founding team came from Björn Ommer, a professor of computer science at LMU Munich. This example shows that high-performance teams can also emerge in Germany in the field of AI.20

New ideas and the creation of something new often originate from people who find a state of flow motivating. The term flow (in the sense of „being in the flow“) was coined by psychology professor Csikszentmihalyi back in 1975. It refers to being completely absorbed in an activity, which usually involves a high level of intrinsic motivation and a change in the perception of time. Interviews in which outstanding creative personalities from various fields look back on their working lives show that their motivation stems primarily from the creative process. For many people, the foundations for possible flow states are often laid in their youth, based on their growth mindset.21

In her book Growth Mindset, Stanford professor Carol Dweck distinguishes between a static and a growth mindset.22 The following figure compares these two mindsets. High-performance systems often have leaders with a growth mindset. An important characteristic is that these people are aware of their talents, but place greater emphasis on their further development and learning processes. In contrast, people with a static worldview place greater hope in the effect of their innate talents.

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella writes that the book had a strong influence on his personal development.23

A person’s self-image and their environment are closely linked. High performance therefore arises from an interplay between the two. Social psychologist Mary Murphy has extended the growth mindset concept to organizations, their culture, and the environment surrounding them:24

  • According to this, a growth culture promotes the potential of all employees. This culture emphasizes collaboration, continuous learning, and the development of skills.
  • A genius culture, on the other hand, believes in innate talent. This leads to internal competition, risk aversion, and a reluctance to admit mistakes.

Recommendations for action for managers are

  • create psychological safety and
  • giving constructive feedback.

However, simplistic application of this approach in practice underestimates the complexity of implementation. This can lead to demotivation among exceptional talents.

This raises the question of whether there are any current examples of a growth culture in Germany. A new bridge in South Westphalia has become a symbol of connective design. The Sauerland motorway is the most important transport link between the Ruhr area and Frankfurt. Due to the risk of collapse, the Rahmedetal bridge near Lüdenscheid, where I grew up, had to be suddenly closed in December 2021 and later blown up. This was a disaster for the economy with its many hidden champions and for the people in the region. Every day, 20,000 vehicles had to be diverted via bypasses and through residential areas. The German Economic Institute estimates the damage to businesses at around 1.5 billion euros. In Germany, new construction normally takes around eight to ten years. However, traffic is already rolling across one side of the A45 bridge via the after a record-breaking four years. This was made possible by smooth cooperation between the parties involved, a new planning procedure, and innovative construction methods. The German Chancellor sees this as a model for other renovations, and for the Minister President of North Rhine-Westphalia, the new benchmark for implementation speed in Germany is called „Rahmede“.25

We can therefore summarize that the culture of socio-technical systems is strongly influenced by the mindset-image of important stakeholders and prevailing design patterns.

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

High-performance cultures are characterized by a growth mindset and a connective pattern. The opposite is a silo culture or, in extreme cases, a culture of self-satisfaction. Here, a static mindset and a divisive design dominate. Descriptions of outstanding leaders often heroize a lone wolf culture. These individuals are attributed with a growth mindset. At the same time, however, the impression is created that their successes were achieved single-handedly and in isolation from others, which is usually not the case. Until a few years ago, a culture of complacency was widespread in Germany. People rested on the successes of the past, but the mindset in politics and business was rather static and not very future-oriented.

Managers serve as role models in this regard. Their growth mindset is transferred to their employees. Conversely, managers with a static mindset and isolating behavior are responsible for the emergence of toxic cultures. Their position of power enables them to oust internal competitors and employees with a growth mindset that they perceive as a threat. Unfortunately, the role of consultants is often to secure and expand the position of power of the „static“ individuals. Attempts by external parties to change silo cultures are usually met with rejection and fail. It is therefore the task of supervisory bodies to review the dysfunctional mindsets of managers and take timely action. If this does not happen, there is a risk of system failure.

On its way to becoming a high-performance system, Europe currently finds itself in a difficult situation.

 

Connection of trustworthy partners from politics, business, science, and society

Europe first needs a resilience program against its enemies from outside and within. US political scientist Francis Fukuyama believes that Trumpism will continue even without Trump. For open democratic societies, this is an extremely dangerous development. He fears a relapse into the world order of the 19th century. It is therefore important that Western societies develop sufficient resilience. It should also be taken into account that tech billionaires primarily act in their own economic interests. The greatest danger for Europe is resignation.26

Marc Tüngler, head of the German Association for the Protection of Securities Holders, laments the lack of political support necessary for innovation and economic restructuring. Germany is no longer internationally competitive in terms of electricity prices, for example. Politicians are responsible for this. Important levers would therefore be an improved location policy and a more innovation-friendly climate. We are far from the necessary solidarity between business and politics. He expects 2026 to be a year of decisions for politicians.27

In his book „Wir Krisenakrobaten“ (We Crisis Acrobats), Stephan Grünewald, co-founder of the Cologne-based opinion research company Rheingold, describes the hope for self-efficacy that would enable our society to overcome the multitude of current crises. His recommendation consists of six points:

  1. Truthfulness (clear identification of problems)
  2. focus (successful national projects)
  3. participation (making one’s own contribution clear)
  4. fairness (unreasonable demands must be perceived as fair)
  5. culture of debate (dealing more productively with changes in perspective) and
  6. solidarity (which must be relearned).

Unfortunately, silo thinking („silodarity“) still prevails at present.28

Martin Keller has returned to Germany from the US to become the new president of the Helmholtz Association. The association comprises 18 independent research centers with almost 48,000 employees and a budget of more than six billion euros. Keller wants to use a plan of action to ensure that Germany remains or becomes a global leader in selected fields of innovation. This requires closer cooperation, e.g., in the context of public-private partnerships (PPP), in which politics, research, and business cooperate in order to become more competitive. He believes it is time to break down old structures.29

In his book „Visionen braucht das Land“ (The Country Needs Visions), Jochen Andritzky, co-initiator of Zukunft-Fabrik 2050, calls on politicians to develop visions of the future that can be discussed and provide guidance. This approach is more promising than short-term pseudo-solutions that merely combat the symptoms.30 This return to the power of vision provides important impetus for management research, which in the past has often been content with incremental improvements. Design-oriented management research aims to be more practice-oriented in this regard.

 

Design-oriented management research in real-world laboratories of change

A research project at Würth has given rise to an AI start-up that could revolutionize the crafts. The aim of the research project conducted by the wholesaler of mounting and fastening material Würth and the AI Lab at the Technical University of Munich was to process inquiries from trade customers in sales more quickly. This led to the spin-off Mercura AI in March 2024, which uses AI to try to solve several problems:

  • Overcoming the shortage of skilled workers
  • increasing productivity for highly complex tasks, and
  • faster processing of inquiries and quotes.

Mercura AI combines semantic models, the recognition of requirements,
company-specific rules, and learning from previous quotes. The software processes both text and speech. The founders have combined AI expertise with industry experience. This example shows the potential of design-oriented management research in companies. 31

Nobel Prize winner Herbert Simon provided important impetus for design-oriented management research. His book „The Sciences of the Artificial,“ published in 1969, is not only a fundamental work on AI, but has also had a strong influence on design theory. The basic idea is that, in addition to the natural sciences, there is a universal science of design. This gave rise to the design methods movement. Not only the technical sciences, but also management science deal with the design of the possible (contingent). In the technical sciences, the design of new things is a natural goal. In management, political science, and social science, the diversity of individual systems and subsystems originating from humans has a specific complexity that is difficult to research purely empirically. Simon’s groundbreaking work emphasizes the interdisciplinarity of design.32

Real-world laboratories of change open up new possibilities for management research. A real-world laboratory (living lab or sandbox) is a research and application space in practice where, for example, companies and their partners design innovative business models. In doing so, they combine research, learning, and action, promote interdisciplinary collaboration, and enable the testing of new legal frameworks (e.g., through the application of experimentation clauses). The concept became known in the 1990s primarily through the work of the Media Lab at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT).33 In Europe, real-world laboratories are primarily intended to create modern forms of regulation (e.g., in urban development). Real-world laboratories have been used relatively little in management research to date. Empirical approaches dominate in dissertations. The advantage of real-world laboratories lies in their ability to better connect theory and practice.

Design-oriented management research is not only taking place at universities, but also increasingly in practice. University lecturers are increasingly supervising creative research approaches by employees in their companies. This approach is mainly used in bachelor’s and master’s theses in dual study programs, in which the course of study is organized in parallel with practical work. In the past, this has also been done more frequently in external dissertations and postdoctoral theses, e.g., by management consultants. The focus here was more on practical relevance. Solving complex problems requires research by interdisciplinary teams, whose members then receive their degrees in their respective fields. Universities should work with partners in the field to combine such projects into programs that can also build on each other (e.g., to design a sovereign AI from Europe).34

The following figure summarizes various possible forms of design-oriented management research. Here, we distinguish between the type of degrees, the employment relationship of the researcher and the project and program types. In a part-time doctorate of a consulting employee, for example, it makes sense to compare the results of projects from several organizations and derive new insights from them. What seems important in this research approach is that design-oriented research projects based on theoretical foundations35 now focus more strongly on concrete application in practice.

Lernprozess Innovationsstrategie

In 2026, we will further develop this approach to management research in the context of designing high-performance systems in which trustworthiness has become an important competitive advantage. One model for this is the start-up ecosystem in Munich, from which other regions can learn.36

 

Conclusion

  • High-performance systems are characterized by their success and trustworthiness. In the current transition phase, Europe should seize this as an opportunity.
  • To do so, companies must master complex realignment processes and become more resilient, digital, and sustainable
  • Such connective strategic management (Strategy 5.0) is one of the fields of action of trustworthy high-performance systems
  • Another field of action is the promotion of high-performance teams with a growth mindset
  • This requires trustworthy partners and closer cooperation between business and politics
  • Real-world laboratories of change open up new opportunities for design-oriented management research.

 

Literature

[1] zu Fürstenberg, J., Kloepfer, I., How good we are is revealed in times of crisis – A wake-up call, Piper 2025

[2] Servatius, H.G., Trimming an organization for performance. In: Harvard Manager, 1988, No. 4, pp. 128-134

[3] Katzenbach, J.R., Smith, D.R., The wisdom of teams – Creating the high performance organization, Harvard Business School Press 1993

[4] de Waal, A., What makes a high performance organization, Warden Press 2019

[5] Servatius, H.G., AI as a tool for strategic management. In: Competivation Blog, May 1, 2025

[6] Sommer, U., US corporations are stronger than ever. In: Handelsblatt, December 29, 2025, pp. 1, 4-6

[7] Alvarez de Souza Soares, P., Holtermann, P., AMD wants to end Nvidia’s monopoly. In: Handelsblatt, January 7, 2026, pp. 18-19

[8] Knees, C., Disinformation as a business risk. In: Handelsblatt, January 7, 2026, pp. 20-21

[9] Merten, M., Companies sinking in AI junk. In: Handelsblatt, January 9, 2026, pp. 20-21

[10] Frankopan, P., „What does Europe have besides handbags and champagne?“ (Interview). In: Handelsblatt, December 19/20/21, 2025, pp. 12-13

[11] Fröndhoff, B., et al., Billions for restructuring. In: Handelsblatt, November 26, 2025, pp. 1, 4-5

[12] Servatius, H.G., Disruption of management education for AI-based realignments. In: Competivation Blog, October 10, 2025

[13] Servatius, H.G., Development and change in strategic management. In: Competivation Blog, September 19, 2025

[14] Servatius, H.G., Triple strategic realignment. In: Competivation Blog, June 7, 2024

[15] Servatius, H.G., Strategic leadership with contextual and relationship-oriented intelligence. In: Competivation Blog, March 14, 2023

[16] Huchzermeier, D. et al., Economy in reform gridlock. In: Handelsblatt, February 2/3/4, 2026, pp. 1, 6-7

[17] Servatius, H.G., Resilience-oriented strategic management. In: Competivation Blog, March 15, 2024

[18] Meiritz, A., „We will certainly remember a no.“ In: Handelsblatt, January 22, 2026, p. 1, 4-5

[19] Koch, M., Can an alliance of middle powers slow Trump down? In: Handelsblatt, January 22, 2026, p. 5

[20] Bomke, L., Germany’s AI hope. In: Handelsblatt, December 2, 2025, p. 1

[21] Czikszentmihalyi, M., Creativity – Flow and the psychology of discovery and invention, Harper Collins 1996

[22] Dweck, C., Mindset – The new psychology of success, Random House 2006

[23] Nadella, S., Hit Refresh – The quest to rediscover Microsoft’s soul and imagine a better future for everyone, Harper Collins 2017

[24] Murphy, M.C., Cultures of growth – How the new science of mindset can transform individuals, teams and organizations, Simon & Schuster 2024

[25] Herwig, M., Linnhoff, C., New A 45 bridge opened. In: Rheinische Post, December 23, 2025, p. A6

[26] Fukuyama, F., „Trumpism is a cry against modernity“ (interview). In: Handelsblatt, December 5/6/7, 2025, pp. 12-13

[27] Tüngler, M., „Friedrich Merz still has it in his hands“ (interview). In: Handelsblatt, December 11, 2025, pp. 22-23

[28] Grünewald, S., We crisis acrobats – Psychogram of an unsettled society, Kiepenheuer & Witsch 2025

[29] Delhaes, D., Architect of a German research breakthrough. In: Handelsblatt, December 30, 2025, p. 13

[30] Andritzky, J., The country needs visions – For long-term policies with the courage to face the future, Herder 2026

[31] Bomke, L., Revolutionizing the trade with AI. In: Handelsblatt, January 7, 2026, p. 26

[32] Simon, H.A., The sciences of the artificial, 3rd ed., MIT Press 1996

[33] Mitchell, W.J., City of bits – Space, place, and the infobahn, MIT Press 1995

[34] Servatius, H.G., AI and the future of management education. In: Competivation Blog, April 9, 2025

[35] Seckler, C., et al., Design sciences across industries – Building bridges for advancing impactful business research. In: Schmalenbach Journal of Business Research, December 9, 2025

[36] Banze, S., Freisinger, G.M., The Munich code. In: Manager Magazin, February 2026, pp. 30-36

Interessiert?

CONNECTIVE MANAGEMENT

Vereinbaren Sie einen unverbindlichen Gesprächstermin:

 














    +49 (0)211 454 3731